7 ms·
Are teachers underpaid? It depends.
- timjahn 15y agoMy wife is a high school English teacher. The ongoing joke with teachers is they get 3 months a year off. What other profession gets that, right? Speaking from experience, she generally brings home work every night (grading, lesson planning, etc). Weekends too. This fluctuates based on time of year (grading a round of research papers, preparing new lessons for a new quarter, etc). Summers off? Kinda. New lessons and curriculums often have to be prepared for the following year. She's been doing that for a bit already whenever our little guy naps. The other part of overlooked is the emotional toll. In my wife's case, she's dealing with high school freshmen, juniors, seniors, all who are one hell of a handful most of the time. Last year, she had a class that had her crying more than a few times. The kids were literally trying to make her cry. But besides all that, teaching is a profession that is charged with preparing and educating our youth for tomorrow. Obviously, teachers go into it knowing this, and often for that very reason. But in my eyes, that's quite a responsibility. There are plenty of better paying jobs out there with less vacation that, at the end of the day, don't make much of a difference. (For the record, my wife's district actually pays pretty well, so I don't think she's underpaid).
- roundsquare 15y ago"But besides all that, teaching is a profession that is charged with preparing and educating our youth for tomorrow. Obviously, teachers go into it knowing this, and often for that very reason. But in my eyes, that's quite a responsibility. There are plenty of better paying jobs out there with less vacation that, at the end of the day, don't make much of a difference." If you ask me, that's all the more reason to increase pay and remove the near absolute job security. (Note: I haven't independently fact checked the job security so if its wrong please let me know). Given how important the job is, doesn't it make sense to align the incentives properly? For the most part, when I hear people disagree with this, they tend to bring up specific problems with things like No Child Left Behind. Its hard to disagree that using bad techniques to measure teacher performance is a bad idea and I don't have a specific better solution, but I don't think that means we should stop trying.
- pmb 15y agoDo you know of any good techniques to measure teacher performance?
- timjahn 15y agoI agree that it's a good reason to increase pay and possibly remove job security. And yes, once a teacher is tenured, barring any obvious crazy behavior, they are basically guaranteed their job regardless (at least in Chicagoland). There are pros and cons to that - my wife and I discuss that subject often. I don't like the idea of tenured teachers not taking that responsibility seriously and just slacking off. My wife argues that it helps the good teachers make real change (since they can't before being tenured for fear of being fired). No Child Left Behind is a big problem if you talk to any teacher. In my wife's district, they will soon be implementing some incentive based teaching practices, where portions of a teachers pay will be tied directly to student performances. And since all high school teaching is geared toward good ACT scores, it will all basically come down to ACT scores (which it does a lot already).
- jseliger 15y ago"Speaking from experience, she generally brings home work every night (grading, lesson planning, etc). Weekends too. This fluctuates based on time of year (grading a round of research papers, preparing new lessons for a new quarter, etc)." That might be true for her. Nonetheless, the plural of anecdote is not data; as I observe in the post: "According to Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data, the average teacher works slightly less than 40 hours per week. If you have better data, I’d like to see it. Note too that people getting teaching degrees at the graduate level get substantially lower GRE scores than those in almost all other disciplines. This will come up later."
- T-R 15y agoNot that I have any reason to doubt the BLS data, but does anyone know of any other data on the issue? Everyone seems to be citing the same pdf.
- odd_sort 15y agoI think what makes people question the data is that the average hours of work per week match up pretty well with the time a teacher spends at school, which is insufficient to cover duties like planning lessons and grading papers (see for example any work-to-contract strike). In any case, the ATUS specifies that its questions are about work done for pay/profit or free for a family business (since teachers typically work more hours than stated in their contract, a lot of work they do is not for pay).
- timjahn 15y agoBingo.
- vacri 15y agoThe BLS data being based off the survey question "How much work did you do yesterday" and extrapolating from that, instead of something more direct like "how much work did you do last week". Anyway, Google is loaded with heaps of research into teacher workloads, this line "if anyone has better data, I'd like to see it" is just a handwaving throwaway line. But if you really do have a problem with anecdotal data, why do things like bring up Bill Gates, who is not only an anecdotal point, but an obvious outlier at that?
- noonespecial 15y agoYou wife is underpaid. She cares. The guy in the class right next to her is overpaid at the very same salary. He doesn't care. That's the super-hard to solve problem a the center of this debate.
- jhaglund 15y agoI think we should all get a few months off a year. I wish the people complaining about teacher "vacation" benefits would instead demand more vacation time for themselves.
- tba 15y agoIt's not hard to believe that the average teacher is paid about what they're worth. The more important question is whether the pay is competitive to attract teachers of sufficient quality.
- tokenadult 15y agoThere is an interesting proposal to get more teachers of better quality for American schools. http://edpro.stanford.edu/hanushek/files_det.asp?FileId=258 http://edpro.stanford.edu/hanushek/files_det.asp?FileId=258 http://edpro.stanford.edu/hanushek/admin/pages/files/uploads/Hanushek%202009%20CNTP%20ch%208.pdf http://edpro.stanford.edu/hanushek/admin/pages/files/uploads... The proposal considers issues of pay, but crucially it also considers issues of other working conditions, including the issue of whether working teachers who do better quality work than other teachers are recognized for that achievement.
- aik 15y agoVery interesting -- thanks for the reference! Will read through it this evening. I sincerely hope it proposes good methods of improving teachers, ones other than the horribly flawed method of judging teachers based on student test scores.
- aik 15y ago> "The first time you teach a class, it’s incredibly hard and time consuming, but the difficulty drops like a logarithm to a relatively low plateau after you’ve done it a few times. This appears to be reflected in data." I'm not entirely sure if this is a good reflection of the teaching role, or at least what it should be. Also, this statement to me gives the impression that teaching is a fairly static or fixed process -- once you've done it a little, your subconscious can take over. Sadly one can get by with that mindset (and unfortunately I've had plenty of teachers who act like they believe this), but any good teacher would be saddened by this. Proper teaching is so much more than just knowing the subject, or the routine. The amount of effort and thought involved in skillfully and effectively teaching any idea or concept to a wide range of different people with different backgrounds and knowledge and world views isn't a task that I believe can become automatic. Good teaching involved understanding your students and understanding where they're coming from and what they know, and tailoring everything you do to get each individual student deeply involved in the subject at hand. That's no easy task, even for seasoned teachers! I'm not suggesting you necessarily are part of this mindset, however sadly so many in the US have such an obscured view of what teaching truly is. In my opinion, that is one of the core problems with education in the US. > "Note too that people getting teaching degrees at the graduate level get substantially lower GRE scores than those in almost all other disciplines." Sorry I don't understand -- what's your point with this, what is this supposed to prove, or how does this contribute to the argument?
- redxaxder 15y agoAs another graduate student who teaches, I can confirm jseliger's claim. Teaching difficulty drops of insanely fast. Don't think of it as making the task automatic, but rather having familiar territory off of which to base the things you say. After one semester teaching a class, you discover what ideas the students tend to find most confusing and what types of errors are the most common. Having leftover notes from the last time you taught saves you you most of the planning work, too.
- aik 15y agoPerhaps we need to talk in scales or include some comparators here. I completely agree that difficulty does drop some with more subject knowledge, teaching experience, and familiarity with the subject and types of questions and students, but by how much really? To me it sounds like it's being suggested that teaching becomes "easy"? Effortless? Not necessarily mentally taxing? Not necessarily time consuming? I can't see how one could _effectively_ teach and think this. Again, I don't see teaching as simply "transferring" facts/knowledge. Students can test well and have no conceptual understanding whatsoever. Or, students can show understanding but have underlying mental models untouched (making them even more confused than previously). Both of these cases are failures. The book "What the Best College Teachers Do" has amazing insights on how involved, dedicated, knowledgeable, and wise very successful and effective teachers are. The amount of thought and effort they put into their courses is staggering, so I'm approaching this discussion from that frame of mind, rather than what the average teacher (or student teacher) does.
- maeon3 15y agoThe reason teacher's salaries are set incorrectly is because supply and demand has been pushed out of the equation. 1. some teachers can't be laid off. 2. schools don't get proportionally more money for exceptional work. 3. most parents are indifferent to maxing out their child's education quality. 4. most of the teachers effort must be applied to the hellions and problem-makers. optimization for max output requires removing the bottom 20% that cause 80% of the problems. If you want teachers to be paid what they are worth, you have to take the Communism out of the school and replace it with that evil Capitalism thing that makes salary tied to how much a worker is worth.
- pmb 15y agoHow can you tell? How can signals propagate through such a system?
- T-R 15y agoI agree with your overall points, but sarcasm and characterizations of those who disagree with you as communists isn't conducive to conversation.
- shaggyfrog 15y agoCouldn't agree more. The nonsense at the end is a disappointing postscript to an otherwise thoughtful comment.
- maeon3 15y agoI see how using the word "Communism" can be taken as an insult, I didn't mean it as one. I'm using the dictionary definition of Communism here. When I think "Communism in American schools", I think of the famous communism quote: "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need."
- jcromartie 15y agoI keep hearing from die-hard conservatives that teachers make "exorbitant" salaries with "unbelievable" benefits, and that they are a drain on our society. On the other hand, every single peer/friend I know who went into teaching is pretty much lower-middle class.
- learc83 15y agoWhen I was in college several of my friends majored in early childhood education. Without a doubt it has to be the easiest major out there. While I was writing papers, my friends were learning how to make name tags with construction paper and crayons, and learning kiddy songs (this is not an exaggeration). The problem is that once you get the degree and jump through the hoops, you're in. That's all there is to it If any idiot can become a teacher, and a bad teacher makes the same a great teacher, then the pay is going to end up as the average of what you'd pay a bad teacher and great one. Side-note: my mom, who also has a degree in early childhood education, tells me that when she was there 30 years ago it was much more academically rigorous.
- sliverstorm 15y agoI gather it depends on how you're entering the field. My mother studies early childhood development with a focus on how it can go wrong (I forget the technical term, but things like severe autism) It doesn't seem to be a 'hard' science, but it's still a science. As such, there's no glitter and construction paper involved, except when they are interacting with the children!
- learc83 15y agoI think that vast majority of aspiring elementary teachers are not going to pursue a degree focusing on developmental disorders.
- sliverstorm 15y agoCertainly. I actually kind agree with your original point, from what I've seen of education majors. I took an education class in college, aced it and got rave reviews on my papers, and I barely even tried. Made me a little concerned about my fellow students in the course.
- miked 15y agoI went to grad school on CS for a year, focusing on AI. I then realized that I was more interested in improving reasoning in people rather than machines, so I switched to Ed. Psych. I can still recall my astonishment at how much lower the quality of grad students in the education school was. A very few bright ones and a whole lot of "dumm". One anecdote: I was focusing for a while on better ways to teach algebra word problems. I put up some examples and not one education grad student, or the professor, could solve even one of them. I'm talking about stuff like "a boat goes 5 miles in an hour against the current and ..." Nada.
- T-R 15y agoI just want to say thanks for the great post. I thought your comment on the other thread was particularly good, I'm glad to see you expand a bit more on it. Honestly, I was a little disappointed to see patio11 reference yummy's comments, since they really leave the impression that he has a horse in this race - it's nice to see a more even handed treatment of the matter.
- sliverstorm 15y agoThis seems to be sort of a catch-22. If the quality of teachers was uniformly high, we could pay them all what they deserve to be paid and not have to worry about leeches so much. If good teachers were paid what they deserve, the quality of teachers would be uniformly high.
- waterside81 15y agoFirst observation: geez teachers in the US don't get paid "that much". In Ontario (province in Canada), teachers can max out after 12 years at > 100K a year, it's not at all unheard of. The teacher's union here is very powerful, for better or worse. I think deciding on how much a teacher "should" earn simply based on the time they put in and then compare it to another profession misses a valuable point - teachers can make a huge difference in the life of a human being. What's that worth to society? If a great math teacher encourages 3 kids to become engineers, then his salary is much less than it should be. I saw a post on HN the other day about a teacher who told an otherwise disillusioned student that he was "gifted". Simply by being told so (he wasn't giften in the traditional sense) completely changed his perspective on school. If he goes on to become a contributing member of society, a good father, and good role model for others, then that teacher is probably worth more than 70K a year.
- learc83 15y agoI agree that a great teacher is worth a substantial sum of money, but in order to pay it we first have to work out some objective metric. It's relatively easy to become a teacher, so if we just start paying every teacher more money we just attract more substandard candidates.
- timjahn 15y agoIt's easy to become a teacher but not as easy to stay a teacher.
- learc83 15y agoWhere did you get that information from. In most districts it's nearly impossible to fire teachers.
- timjahn 15y agoIt's nearly impossible to fire teachers, but staying a teacher is tough in terms of dealing with the emotional and mental stress (or simply wanting more money). http://www.timesdaily.com/article/20090222/articles/902220325?Title=Teacher-dropout-rate-higher-than-students- http://www.timesdaily.com/article/20090222/articles/90222032...
- antidaily 15y agoThere's something uniquely American about bitching whenever someone has something you don't have. Most people have shitty benefits and 2 weeks off. The rest of the world has free healthcare and double the vacation days. But the problem isnt that our employers are cheap bastards, its that the teachers' unions are too strong. Right.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- njloof 15y agoThe article's comparison to teaching undergrads is just sad.