4 ms·
> Mac software and app industry has died. Even after notarising apps they show malicious popup to users. I maintain a handful of open source apps for macOS, an
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> Mac software and app industry has died. Even after notarising apps they show malicious popup to users.
I maintain a handful of open source apps for macOS, and have for years. If I don't pay the $100 Apple tax, macOS will treat those apps as if they're radioactive, and it will trick users into believing the apps are either broken or malicious.
In order to run them, users must know how to change arcane settings and do a magic ritual with the UI, otherwise they just won't open.
If the tables were turned and it was Linux that wouldn't run apps that were not signed and approved by Red Hat without having to jump through arcane hoops first, people would be rightfully pointing out how user and developer hostile it is.
> They killed the industry.
Not only that, they helped usher in the race to the bottom when it comes to the app distribution market. Now everyone expects to spend a dollar or two for an app if they're spending anything at all. They also killed the paid update/upgrade model for apps.
- smoldesu 5y agoAbsolutely this. Apple's holier-than-thou approach to every settlement they reach is starting to blow back in their face, as the rest of our economy starts to realize how parasitic and destructive this tax-collection model is. Now that Apple can effectively set their own margins, they have no incentive to treat their users or developers fairly, and recently have started to bring the hammer down. I had a few friends who also maintained open source apps for iOS, and they constantly lamented how impossible it was to get Apple to review their accusation that their open-source manual app was malware.
- hahahasure 5y agoMarket and use emotion, trick the masses. The intellectuals will be dragged along.
- Const-me 5y agoWindows is getting close to macOS in that regard. Specifically, both browser and OS are arbitrarily marking installers as malware, scaring users. Even digital signatures don't help. The only reliable workaround is publishing through Windows store.
- wila 5y agoYep, been bitten by that myself. Nowadays normal (OV) codesign signatures still trigger warnings for users on startup. Only a much more expensive EV codesign certificate guarantees a silent install. The OV codesign certificate can become accepted by Smartscreen, but it can take a very long time with many downloads (in my case it took over 5 months, with thousands of downloads)
- CaptainZapp 5y agoCan you provide an example? I never had an issue with installing (mostly signed) Windows software.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 5y ago> If I don't pay the $100 Apple tax Please. If you can’t make enough in an entire damn year to cover that $100, you need to look at what you’re doing. Hell I’ve seen obscure open source projects get more than $100 in donations every single month. If people see any value in your work, then that $100 is not a barrier at all.
- mastersummoner 5y agoNot every OSS developer does, or wants to, request donations for their software.
- webmobdev 5y agoYou make a good point for commercial products. But what about open source or closed source softwares that the developer wants to distribute for free?
- heavyset_go 5y agoI'm not begging for donations, nor am I dealing with the tax implications of taking donations, sorry. I made these apps before macOS enforced the $100 Apple tax on all apps. I would not have created them today if it meant jumping through the hoops that Apple imposes in 2021. It actually costs me money to maintain these apps, because the time I take to maintain them could be time I bill to a client.
- Razengan 5y ago> I'm not begging for donations No, you’re begging for free access to millions of users to do whatever you want with them. Which Android/Windows/Linux will happily give you.
- Saris 5y agoWhat about OSS devs who don't make money from their apps? There are not very many OSS apps on the iOS app store, probably caused by the difficulty in getting an app published.
- 5y ago