3 ms·
Just briefly went through the paper, the model seems overly simplistic to make this extraordinary claim. Plus, they are not looking at confounding factors, time
by ekianjo 5y ago
Just briefly went through the paper, the model seems overly simplistic to make this extraordinary claim. Plus, they are not looking at confounding factors, time of day, etc, etc... If you want to prove that one variable is stronger than others, you need to include more than one variable...
- lixtra 5y agoThe title and the fact that they calculated the damage down to the dollar are good signs that the value of the paper is in learning from its flaws, not the conclusions.
- scotty79 5y agoThey didn't calculate health benefits that Pokemon GO induced by making people walk and bike more.
- emodendroket 5y agoIt would seem to indicate a wild lack of focus if the same paper was analyzing traffic fatalities and the health benefits of walking.
- aaron695 5y ago"policy recommendations require a consideration of both costs and benefits and we have made no attempt to calculate the economic benefits of using mobile devices while driving. We acknowledge, though, that identifying any economic benefits of playing Pokémon GO while driving stretches our imaginations" They narrowed it down to just driving. It's a bit weaselly to not try and find the value. Napkin Maths, a movie is $5 per hour. Driving for a hour playing Pokemon Go is worth ~$5. But it's also worth ~$5 per hour walking. So the Napkin Maths fails.
- fito 5y agoIndeed. It’s tiring for me to keep reading papers written by people who believe in money as if it were the only driving force in people’s lives.