2 ms·
The problem with getting a stream of someone's comments is that (unlike blog posts and tweets) comments are not written to stand alone. One can reduce the prob
by hollerith 15y ago
The problem with getting a stream of someone's comments is that (unlike blog posts and tweets) comments are not written to stand alone.
One can reduce the problem by always including the parent, but that is often too much or too little context. For a stream of omments to be worth reading really requires some indication of what older comments are necessary to understand any given comment and probably some changes in the habits of comment writers.
And yeah, the inability to make views worth reading of comments by selected authors makes me try to stay away from trees of comments like we see on reddit and HN. (HN however has other things going for it though that offset my dislike of trees of comments.)
- akkartik 15y agoYeah. I've tried to make the most of current mores with the 'x more comments' link, which shows all of a comment's parents. What do you think of that?
- pw 15y agoI think the 'x more comments' interface is great. I've always followed certain HNers (most recently using RSS feeds from searchyc.com), but seeing their comments in context was never easy.
- hollerith 15y agoI noticed that link, but did not try it because I was not really paying attention and assumed it was like those links on Reddit or (old) Slashdot that hide low-score comments. I would have been more likely to try it if the link said, "Show x more comments above," since that phrasing is used on Less Wrong, or, "Show context." (Trying it now.)
- akkartik 15y agoAh, thanks for the pointer to lesswrong!