4 ms·
What is the author's thesis? I skimmed and read and re-read, but didn't figure it out. It's well known that elite universities are elitist in their admissions
by wolverine876 5y ago
What is the author's thesis? I skimmed and read and re-read, but didn't figure it out.
It's well known that elite universities are elitist in their admissions and have over-large endowments. And the elite universities have acted on it, and many of their new classes are very different. And it's well known that the rest of the U.S. educational system is underfunded.
> Sen. Tom Cotton, of all political leaders, suggested taxing private colleges with large endowments, and redirecting funds to vocational training.
It's not a surprise. Cotton and his party see Ivy League universities as institutions of the political opposition, whom they attack and want to punish and diminish.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rkk3 5y ago> What is the author's thesis? I skimmed and read and re-read, but didn't figure it out. Same. I think they are hoping Biden will put more money into public schools and stop preferential tax treatments for the large endowments. > It's not a surprise. Cotton and his party see Ivy League universities as institutions of the political opposition, whom they attack and want to punish and diminish. Tom Cotton... Harvard University BA , JD You are right that it fits the public narrative & rhetoric, but many (perhaps most) of them went to elite schools. It is probably just posturing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Cotton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Cotton
- tootie 5y agoOn that note, the liberal cry of student loan forgiveness will overwhelmingly favor people who went to expensive private colleges. Taxing big endowments seems pretty senseless and doesn't create any positive incentives either. More support and less stigma against state schools would probably do the most good.
- rkk3 5y ago> the liberal cry of student loan forgiveness will overwhelmingly favor people who went to expensive private colleges. True, but you can be expensive & private & not be elite (most of them are not by definition).
- wolverine876 5y ago> the liberal cry of student loan forgiveness What if we dropped the inflammatory political attack and just talked about loan forgiveness? Can an idea or anything else be depoliticized. And it does have some benefits, in addition to that drawback. I'm not sure about the extent or nature of it - many leading colleges reduce their prices to get the students in the door - has anyone studied it?
- tootie 5y agoI count myself as a liberal but also a wonky liberal. The fact the progressive agitators don't have sound evidence for the validity of their ideas beyond number of retweets bugs the hell out of me. Student loan forgiveness would most likely be a net positive it's just going to be quite expensive for relatively little reward. Incremental wins on health care and progressive taxation will be much simpler and more beneficial.
- wolverine876 5y agoYou're a "wonky liberal", but it's the lack of sound evidence for progressive ideas that bothers you? Issues like climate change? Mass incarceration? Racism? Universal health care? Vaccinating people and wearing masks (not a position limited to progressives)? There's not another part of the political spectrum that lacks sound evidence? That's a bit mind-boggling, but not the first time I've seen it. My hypothesis: Middle-ground liberals are intimidated by abusive conservatives, but they feel safe criticizing progressives. You won't get flamed on HN, for example, for what you posted.
- tootie 5y agoNo, no not at all. I'm only talking about student loan debt. I'm 100% on board with everything else.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoThis is correct, and one of the many reasons why I’m very glad President Biden came out against blanket loan forgiveness at the high end of $50k even though Schumer, AOC, Warren support it
- wolverine876 5y ago> Tom Cotton... Harvard University BA , JD > You are right that it fits the public narrative & rhetoric, but many (perhaps most) of them went to elite schools. It is probably just posturing. Oh yeah; I didn't mean to say otherwise. Most of what they say is posturing, IMHO.
- handrous 5y agoForget elite universities: IIRC exactly one of the last eight Presidential candidates (from the two parties that matters) in the general election didn't attend a private prep high school. (Hillary Clinton, is the one who didn't). [EDIT] I know Cotton isn't one of them, I'm just pointing out that this elitism sure as hell appears to be a driving factor in who's on top in both parties.
- rkk3 5y agoDon't think Biden went to prep school, He didn't even go to an Ivy. So 7/9? Edit: Correction I forgot McCain Bush - Philips Academy Gore - St Albans School Kerry - St Pauls Obama - Punahou School (On scholarship!) McCain - Episcopal High School Romney - Cranbrook School Trump - New York Military Academy
- handrous 5y agoBiden: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archmere_Academy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archmere_Academy
- tester756 5y ago>It is probably just posturing. What makes you think so? Just because I have degree, then it doesn't mean that I'm not talking shit about academia
- barry-cotter 5y ago> And the elite universities have acted on it, and many of their new classes are very different. No less elitist though. The idea of a selective college is elitist. The more selective, the more elitist. All the progressive talk is cant.
- wolverine876 5y ago>> And the elite universities have acted on it, and many of their new classes are very different. > No less elitist though. The idea of a selective college is elitist. What does that mean? By that definition, everything selective is 'elitist', including my high school wrestling team. By non-elitist, we generally mean it's not biased in favor of the people who are already in society's elite. Some top colleges now admit much more economically and ethnically diverse students. I've seen the applications, and they've reduced processes that select for children of the elite (such as standardized tests). In other words, they aren't admitting the children of elite (or not as much) - I think that is meaningful. (I wish I could provide some citations, but I don't have time or anything at my fingertips.) > All the progressive talk is cant. Am I responding to nothing more than mindless anti-progressivism?
- rejectedandsad 5y agoI mean, yeah that is elitist especially because the point of college is education not to compete together as a team. I went to CC in high school and a non selective engineering school. I’ve seen non-elitist and non-elite institutions.
- wolverine876 5y ago> that is elitist especially because the point of college is education not to compete together as a team I don't understand how the latter implies the former ?
- rejectedandsad 5y agoColleges should aim to educate not compete with each other. The team analogy doesn’t work.
- hecubus 5y agoIn case it helps, I found out about the article from this interview here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4Aji9tl2D8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4Aji9tl2D8. I hadn't heard of Sam Haselby before, but Matt Stoller is an interesting antitrust-oriented critic of big tech.
- nineplay 5y agoThe article was all over the map and didn't have anything inciteful to say. I was amused to see the college admissions scandal brought up since only one of the several colleges involved was Ivy League.
- bo1024 5y agoI also couldn't follow. It seemed to jump between topics without making a connection or using them to make a central point that I could see.