I'm not disputing that it creates an incentive for making energy production more efficient. It does! In the analogy I gave, there's definitely an incentive for

I'm not disputing that it creates an incentive for making energy production more efficient. It does! In the analogy I gave, there's definitely an incentive for building more highways ("There would be an incredible incentive for expanding LA's highway infrastructure") - it's just that this incentive is, at best, completely useless to existing commuters taking the highways. I'm also not claiming that it's bad for energy to be produced and consumed. It's not! It's just irrelevant if you're looking to consume electricity, and someone else is producing and immediately consuming it. And it's bad for you as a consumer if production goes up and consumption goes up by even more. I have no idea what your point is about the Sun.