3 ms·
Since most STEM workers have fairly successful professional and personal lives and whatever behaviours you associate with Autism Spectrum Disorder don't lead to
by renewiltord 5y ago
Since most STEM workers have fairly successful professional and personal lives and whatever behaviours you associate with Autism Spectrum Disorder don't lead to any harm in their lives, it's hard to accept that what they have is a 'disorder' in any sense any more than working hard is mild workaholism.
If you have some cluster of traits that don't hurt you, then imho they're just traits, not a disorder.
- bawolff 5y agoDo STEM workers have succesful personal lives relative to people in other fields? I have no idea, but there are some sterotypes that they are below average. Would be interesting to see studies on that.
- ggggtez 5y agoSTEM make more money, and more money is associated with happiness. But you probably wanted something more conclusive.
- dragonwriter 5y agoX correlates with Y & Y correlates with Z doesn't imply X correlates with Z.
- bawolff 5y agoAlso money generally doesn't correlate with happiness past a certain very basic point.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoGive me some so I can test that theory ;)
- hyperpape 5y agoThis was a widely shared and delightfully counterintuitive idea, but it’s not right. The first source that comes to mind is Dan Luu’s summary, but it’s been widely reported (though sadly hasn’t spread as wide as the original claim) https://danluu.com/dunning-kruger/ https://danluu.com/dunning-kruger/.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bawolff 5y agoIm not sure im totally convinced (based on that article, i didn't read the citations) - that graph cuts off at a pretty low annual salary (200k). That's certainly a comfortable lifestyle, but that's still within the realm of what normal people on the high end of a good job make. Maybe the happiness cut off is further into the aristocracy - even if the increase in happiness is logrithmic in the amount of money, and that contunues. Logs grow slowly, maybe at some point it effectively doesn't matter.
- ggggtez 5y agoPretty sure there was recent research which says the opposite: people always have more appetite for money, just that the amount of money required is nonlinear with respect to wealth. Rich people still get happy when they make money, and sad when they lose it. It's kind of crazy to think otherwise.
- renewiltord 5y agoPersonal lives are complex things, certainly, and no single metric can capture 'success' or 'failure' on them. However, one piece of evidence is the per-occupation divorce rate: https://flowingdata.com/2017/07/25/divorce-and-occupation https://flowingdata.com/2017/07/25/divorce-and-occupation Software folks are really good about not getting divorced. And they have money, so they could if they wanted to.
- bawolff 5y agoThat statistic could go both ways though. Can't get divorced if you never get married.
- renewiltord 5y agoThis information is in the Census data releases. You can test your hypothesis. Do share if you find anything interesting.
- dnautics 5y agoMy guess is that a large part of it is social. In STEM you don't have to be as personable to succeed. I'm perfectly capable of bringing a face, but even though I'm an extrovert god damn is it exhausting. Thankfully, working in stem I don't have to, so I don't, and I save my energy for non-work socialization.
- bawolff 5y agoIf you find it exhausting you're probably not an extrovert (extrovert/introvert is just about how much energy social stuff takes you, it has nothing to do with how much you socialize, how good you are at it, or how much you like it)
- dnautics 5y agoI mean what I said: I find it exhausting to bring a face. When I'm interacting with people in a more organic setting I gain energy. -- definitely an extrovert. My primary non-work activity is highly social (social dance).
- gopalv 5y ago> If you have some cluster of traits that don't hurt you, then imho they're just traits, not a disorder Even more relevant is that some things could be cliff disorders, where it is actually beneficial till it actually falls over some point. Like Icarus flying, but takes him too close to the sun. Being obsessive about details making things or being paranoid about what you eat are probably great things to start with, but overrides its own utility at some point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kokanator 5y agoThese traits are typically in clusters. You may have an amazing brain trait that accelerates your success and also have a sensory processing disorder which creates great discomfort. The cliff question would seem to be a very personal question. Where does that cliff exist? What traits create a cliff? ( not really looking for answer ) I have two autists in my house. For them autism has created some substantial struggles when dealing with the world in general. However, their ( what I call super powers ) have allowed them great success in their given fields ( cs and research ). Both see the world substantially different than their mom and I do. Their view is often, simple and more forgiving. Autists have and continue to make great contributions to the neural typical world. My hope is that we are not on a road to eliminate these individuals from our world.[0] [0]https://www.appliedbehavioranalysisprograms.com/historys-30-most-inspiring-people-on-the-autism-spectrum/ https://www.appliedbehavioranalysisprograms.com/historys-30-...
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoThis is such a good point. For example, there’s fastidious, which is a great to have in at least some members of a team, or to be able to draw on as a skill or trait for oneself; and then there’s the same taken to an extreme which manifests as disorders such as OCD, hoarding, etc.
- skissane 5y agoSome people have broad autism phenotype (BAP), which means they have many of the traits of ASD, but those traits are not sufficiently disabling to justify the label of a disorder. And BAP is more common among STEM workers than the general population. However, the boundary between BAP and ASD is not fixed. Different clinicians draw the line at different places, and it is moving over time. And which side of the line one ends up on can be determined by external life experiences. A person with BAP who lives a life full of luck and supportive environments may never be disabled by their traits to the extent that an ASD diagnosis is warranted. Give the same person worse luck and a more adverse environment, and the same traits may become much more disabling, and they may end up with an ASD diagnosis as a result. So, fundamentally the same person, whether they had ASD was determined not by who they are but by what their environment is. This is part of what annoys me about some of these popular lines that "autistic people" and "neurotypical people" are "wired differently". Are people with BAP "neurotypical" or not? And sometimes the label is determined, not by one's "wiring", but by stuff going on in the world outside one's head, by society and culture and family and friends and fate and fortune.
- ivan888 5y ago> whatever behaviours you associate with Autism Spectrum Disorder don't lead to any harm in their lives It doesn't appear that the op made this claim. I think I understand your perspective. I think there are some ASD associated traits which may result in sort of a tradeoff for some STEM workers. E.g someone who has a difficulty forming interpersonal relationships (negative) may thus have more free time to pursue academics and outperform their more social peers (positive). This seems more like what the op was talking about being able to observe.