3 ms·
> I was originally fascinated by crypto, but the more I've come to understand it the more I suspect the world has lost its mind. I sort of agree. I have 12 Ch
by ryan29 5y ago
> I was originally fascinated by crypto, but the more I've come to understand it the more I suspect the world has lost its mind.
I sort of agree. I have 12 Chia (XCH) so I've been learning about crypto for the last couple months. There's some neat tech alongside crypto, but all of it is completely ruined by the "currency" portion of the deal.
Here are the issues I have with it.
A lot of governments treat it as a security rather than a currency and that comes along with a ton of accounting and tax implications. In Canada, every exchange of crypto is a taxable event. In the US I've seen people claiming they're supposed to consider _mining_ a block a taxable event.
It's hard to spend and there are so many fees it's insane. I wanted to try buying a .eth domain last week, but I gave up when I realized my exchange charges $20 for a single transaction to move my ETH into a private wallet.
The fees are extremely hard to figure out if you're not a crypto veteran. I couldn't even figure out what the transaction fees for buying a .eth domain would end up being. The idea of variable rate fees for transactions is so dumb it's almost funny.
Being a security, the KYC/AML add a ton of friction for anyone trying to get into the ecosystem. I had to give crypto.com an astronomical amount of information to set up an account. Then, after all that, they don't have _all_ the currencies I'd like to buy and they'd probably charge me an arm and a leg for those transfers anyway.
For example, I wanted to try to buy a Handshake (HNS) domain, but they only accept 2 currencies; BTC and HNS. If I want to buy HNS from them I need to go though the KYC/AML verification process. Repeat this for every crypto currency where you can't buy it on your regular exchange or where you don't want to spend a fortune in withdrawal fees. I'd have to pay $14 right now to transfer BTC from crypto.com. That's ONE transaction.
Then, add in the complexity of swapping between currency which my country (Canada) considers a taxable event. If I use BTC at namebase.io to buy a Handshake domain, does that get swapped to HNS first. I assume so since the blockchain is only going to work with HNS. Who's responsible for that event? Me?
The immutable nature of the blockchains has downsides. The .eth domains are a good example of this. A ton of huge trademarked names are being squatted on, but there's no way to enforce IP laws. The crypto crowd considers this a strength, but it's not. None of the big tech companies are going to buy in to a system where their IP can be abused. IMO they'll actively fight against it's adoption. However, as soon as you take away the immutability, you have another version of ICANN, so where's the benefit?
I would have spent $200 on crypto domains last week, but it was such a pain in the ass that I spent $0. The space is 10 years old and I can't even spend my money on anything after making an effort at it (for several hours).
BTW, I've been trying to find a way to sell my XCH on a US/Canada banked exchange since they were at $1500 and I _still_ can't sell them as they dropped below $500 today. The only way to do it is to shuffle between currencies and exchanges. So I need to trigger a ton of taxable events and shift my money around in a way that looks like I'm a money launderer. No thanks. That's not for me.
End rant I guess. Lol.
- pcthrowaway 5y agoMining a block is a taxable event in Canada as well. It's just an income event, rather than a capital gains event (as it probably should be). Staking rewards aren't specifically addressed by the CRA, but it's likely those also fall under income events. I believe energy costs towards mining can be written off as a business expense, but I'm not really interested in mining, so I haven't looked into it that much.
- ryan29 5y agoAnything I could find says that if it's done as a hobby it's only dispositions that count. That really hammers home my point though. It's literally unusable by the average person because the taxes are so complicated you'll need an accountant that specializes in crypto currency to do your taxes at the end of the year. If the price drops to $100 and I'm holding $1000 I'll delete the damn things rather than dealing with the taxes on them. What a joke.
- pcthrowaway 5y agoAlso, to your point about getting rid of your Chia, I think 'looking like money laundering' sort of just comes with the territory right now. It's easy enough to trade it for something on Binance/Newton/Kraken and then cash out that way. In Canada, Kraken/Newton will allow you to cash out directly. Binance has more markets in case you need to trade it to something else first.
- ryan29 5y agoAFAIK Kraken and Newton don't trade Chia. Newton looks very, very similar to Coinberry. None of them trade Chia yet. The crazy thing is that on crypto.com I can _buy_ Chia, but I can't transfer in and sell it. > I think 'looking like money laundering' sort of just comes with the territory right now. Lmao. That'll be a hard pass for me then. $10k would be a lot of money for me, but I'd rather watch what I thought might be $5-10k disappear instead of ending up on the government's radar.