7 ms·
NASA hacked because of unauthorized Raspberry Pi connected to its network (2019)
- anonymousiam 5y ago"The robot looks a lot like the US space agency's (Nasa) Spirit and Opportunity vehicles from the 2000s." https://www.yahoo.com/news/us-satellite-looks-down-chinas-114038554.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/us-satellite-looks-down-chinas-11...
- nerpderp82 5y agoMac addresses should be registered with the network and run an endpoint security agent to continue physical access.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIsn't 802.11x the right solution? MAC addresses can be faked easily; 802.11x forces actual authentication (and encryption, IIRC?).
- randmeerkat 5y ago“802.11x is generic term to refer to the IEEE 802.11 standard for defining communication over a wireless LAN (WLAN).” https://www.techopedia.com/definition/508/ieee-80211x https://www.techopedia.com/definition/508/ieee-80211x I believe you’re looking for 802.1X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.1X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.1X
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoOops, I've been misreading that for ages; thanks for the correction.
- rnhmjoj 5y agoThe protocol (802.1x) is a mean of granting/denying access to a network based on a set of rules. It does authentication, which is itself end-to-end encrypted, but it doesn't provide confidentiality, meaning no encryption. Also, I'm not sure, but I believe it doesn't protect againts active MITM attacks (also meaning injecting packets). There's another set of protocols, 802.1AE or MACSec, which should do what you ask.
- tinus_hn 5y agoMac addresses are useless for security purposes. There really is no right solution using a Pi, everything is on the SD card and there is no encryption possible. It’s a bit too open.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoFrom June 21, 2019
- NeuNeurosis 5y agoRemind you of Mr.Robot anyone?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yellow_lead 5y agoA consultant who works with NASA once told me that there was an incident where they had exposed several petabytes of data to the public Internet. Because no one had the storage capability for the data though, they wrote off the security incident completely.
- silicon2401 5y agoThat's pretty hilarious. Reminds me of construction equipment. At some point on some highway, I realized construction machines, materials, and so on are probably pretty expensive, yet they're just left out there without even a tarp to hide them. I guess they're so difficult to move it wouldn't be worth even trying to steal them.
- cameronh90 5y agoMaybe theft is proportional to value density?
- milesvp 5y agoTheft is often a crime of convenience. It’s counterintuitive, but thefts actually tend to go down during recessions. People just don’t leave the house as much, so they don’t have as many opportunities to steal. Source: good friend was a public defender
- pope_meat 5y agoThey're all tagged with GPS trackers these days. The rare case of heavy equipment like that being stolen almost always results in recovery because of that. I would recommend just trying to steal some parts of the machine, rather than the whole thing. If you do enough research and presell the parts before taking them you would probably get away with it for a while. Thought exercise only, I ain't cut out for the life of crime.
- Arrath 5y agoHydraulic cylinders would probably be a good place to start, just based on anecdata from seeing equipment down for long, expensive periods of time as cylinders go off for rebuild/reseal/resleeving.
- project2501a 5y ago> "The attacker exfiltrated approximately 500 megabytes of data from 23 files, 2 of which contained International Traffic in Arms Regulations information related to the Mars Science Laboratory mission," the NASA OIG said. wait, what? ITAR REGULATION for Mars Missions??
- sigstoat 5y agofrom the training sessions they made me take ages ago, most everything about space-flight hardware and control systems is ITAR-restricted.
- marsokod 5y agoNot anymore. Now it's almost everything is EAR, and ITAR is restricted to a smaller subset nowadays. EAR is still painful but much less than ITAR - if you just want to use an EAR product and you are in a NATO country, handling the restriction is fairly smooth.
- sdenton4 5y agoTo mangle an old saying: A sufficiently advanced space program is indistinguishable from an intercontinental ballistic missile program.
- ben_w 5y agoAnd to quote a different famous author: "A reaction drive's efficiency as a weapon is in direct proportion to its efficiency as a drive."
- jandrese 5y agoThis is also why it is silly to even consider defense against a hostile alien threat that arrives in our solar system. If they have a spacecraft capable of crossing interstellar distances then wiping out all life on Earth without warning is a trivial problem.
- klhutchins 5y agoI'm curious if it was wired or wireless? Also was it just someones hobby raspberry with default creds or was it there for this purpose?
- matt_morgan 5y agoBut how did the Pi get there? Was it just some NASA employee's project? Or was there physical intrustion and the Pi was part of the plan?
- aequitas 5y agoA lot of companies allow RPi's or Nuc's to be installed into the network by teams to setup interactive scrum boards and (CI) monitoring displays. For this reason they are littered with (personal) access tokens with broad permissions on CI and other important systems. Most of the time these have barely any configuration management or security best practices as the teams want to manage these themselves (Devops is what the developers call it, but there is hardly any Ops in there). Often this initiative comes from the actual Ops not being able to provide the services the developers need, for whatever technical or political reason .
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoI'm interpreting 'The OIG report said the hackers used "a compromised external user system" to access the JPL missions network.' as the Pi being a legitimate user's project.
- zzyzxd 5y ago> The report blamed the JPL's failure to segment its internal network into smaller segments Network boundary can never provide strong enough security protection. No matter how small each segment is. Just because a device is in your network doesn't mean you can trust it. Implement authnz correctly everywhere and make sure the system can verify "if you are who you say you are" is more efficient.
- Nursie 5y agoThis was the old scare scenario for "Plug Computing" way back when. It was new that you could fit a capable linux system (>1GHz core, >.5GB RAM, network interfaces, bluetooth etc) into something that hung off a socket and looked just like any other power supply or dumb device or whatever. Of course that was forseeing malicious placement of something that would be scanning for vulnerabilities, rather than a remote exploit of an unsecured device on a secure network.
- duxup 5y agoI once worked with a company who on occasion sent people to very secure sites. (yes I've told this story before) You arrived at the facility in a rental car with your keys, clothing, ID (credit cards were ok and could be left in the car), and anything you needed to do the job (laptop, hardware, whatever). You were told to expect to leave with your clothes, keys, ID, and rental car (obviously the previously mentioned credit cards). You parked at the gate, were blindfolded, and escorted to the place you did your job, and then the same process out. NOTHING left the facility beyond those things, even the front gate. (Car was searched and anything in the car might be confiscated). I honestly think that's a level of security (well maybe without blindfold) that many places will eventually have to adopt.
- martini333 5y agoReminds me of Mr. Robot
- rootbear 5y agoI'm at NASA and a while ago I wanted to experiment with using Pi's to monitor experimental setups, instead of using full-on PCs as we do now, which would save a ton of money. Trying to get permission to put one on the network, even for just a quick test, was so difficult I gave up. And that was a few years ago, now we have so much mandatory compliance monitoring software, I don't know if it would even be possible anymore. Some of those packages may not be available for the Pi, even if it were running a supported OS like Ubuntu instead of Raspios. I understand why incidents like this one have made NASA management extra sensitive to IT security matters, but it sure feels like a creativity straight-jacket at times. There is not much fun in being an SA at NASA these days, I'm sorry to say.
- FreshFries 5y ago> I wanted to experiment with using Pi's to monitor experimental setups, instead of using full-on PCs as we do now, which would save a ton of money. Because the costs you think of are but a fraction of the costs that are involved in keeping them accounted for, updated, monitored etc. I have these discussions with creative individuals far too often :)
- knightofmars 5y agoThe Rasperry Pi really isn't the point here. It's really about general bad security hygiene. The section labeled "HACKERS DESCRIBED AS AN APT" covers the actual problems that allowed this to happen. The NASA combined with Rasperry Pi components of the headline are more clickbait than anything.