3 ms·
I enjoyed that read. I suspect that it probably pissed off a few folks. I'm a grizzled, scarred old codger that spent most of his career, saying "Are you sure
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I enjoyed that read. I suspect that it probably pissed off a few folks.
I'm a grizzled, scarred old codger that spent most of his career, saying "Are you sure that's a good idea?", only to be ignored, and then put in charge of mopping up the blood.
I have learned that "I told you so." is absolutely, 1000% worthless. It doesn't even feel good, saying it.
What I have learned, is that, when I see someone dancing along a cliff edge, I quietly start figuring out where the mops are kept. If that person has any authority at all, I'll never be able to stop them from their calisthenics.
One of my favorite quotes is one that pretty much describes "hedgehogs":
"There's always an easy solution to every human problem; Neat, plausible and wrong."
There's another one, by the same chap (H. L. Mencken):
"The fact that I have no remedy for all the sorrows of the world is no reason for my accepting yours. It simply supports the strong probability that yours is a fake."
Of course, the issue is that for every 10,000 appalling, messy, featured-on-rotten-dot-com failures, there's one spectacular success. Since humans are biased to think of successful outcomes as more likely than they actually are, the ingredients for that success become a "recipe," and are slavishly reproduced, without any critical thought, or flexibility.
It's like a witch doctor's formula for headache cure is bat urine, dandruff from the shrunken head of a fallen warrior chief, eye of newt, boiled alligator snot, and ground willow bark. The willow bark is what did it, but the dandruff thing is the most eye-catching ingredient, so it gets the credit, and everytime the chief gets a hangover, they start a war.
Somewhere down the road, a copycat substitutes hemlock for the willow bark, and headaches become a death sentence.
- goodpoint 5y ago> I have learned that "I told you so." is absolutely, 1000% worthless. This is proof of bad company culture. Doing post-mortems is important to learn what went wrong in the decision process and how to prevent it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoDifferent thing. "I told you so" is a smug, nasty statement. It wins no friends, and closes the ears of those most in need of it. A postmortem is a clinical, reasoned, and scientific review. Everyone is on board, and agrees to abide by the results. I worked for a Japanese company, for a long time. I made some colossal mistakes, during my tenure, and was told "That was, indeed, a mistake. We expect you to mitigate it, and not repeat it." Often, I would actually get more trust and responsibility, afterwards.
- sn41 5y agoYup, I tell my teammates, fix the error, not the blame. I refuse to find who did wrong. After an initial hesitation, suddenly everybody jumps to it and solves the issue.
- croon 5y agoSometimes it's necessary to find who did something to find out what happened (maybe), but if the culture is good that's not a problem. I've had no issues admitting mistakes at my places of work, and vice versa: "This is what happened/I did, which led to this. We fix it this way. What can we do to prevent it/similar things happening in the future?". Edit: People do most things with good intentions and for hopefully good reasons. When things go wrong it's usually down to unforeseen interactions or second order effects (or brain farts), and/or a lacking review process. The person making "the mistake" is usually just the last person crossing a faulty bridge, and if it wasn't them it would've been the next person. It's not a problem identifying the person if everyone realizes we all want a sturdy bridge.
- sn41 5y agoWhat you say makes sense in a good atmosphere. I work in a very toxic culture. Once people start blaming someone, their own blood boils with their rhetoric, and then it becomes a bitter fight. I see it as etiology vs. teleology - rather than thinking "how did we get here?" we think "how do we get out of here?" The two are interrelated, but the second somehow gets things moving, and reduces resentment in toxic workplaces.
- throwaway_fjmr 5y agoHow do you, or how should anyone in a similar situation learn that actions have consequences? I work for a large (not FAANG but spatially close) ecommerce company, and I’ve yet to see substantial changes or learnings after outages or mistakes. I often find that wishy-washy post-mortems smear responsibility and deflect accountability. This doesn’t incentivize a change in behavior, and when people blindly get more trust, they often seem to simply repeat mistakes. I think I’ve yet to master post-mortems and transforming “I told you so”s into improvements - I’d appreciate tips and ideas, thanks!
- VoodooJuJu 5y agoI'd rather be the guy that sells the mops. These people won't respect you until you take their money.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI believe those are called "Security Consultants."
- sn41 5y agoI see myself in the same role in my organization, except that I think in terms of a different bodily (semi) fluid. I even have had crises of confidence, thinking that "I told you syndrome" is a psychological issue with me. I do tend to be overcautious, and tend to underachieve because of it. But I get a grim satisfaction in knowing that when the next time the bodily fluid hits the air circulator, my pail and mop will make it liveable again. There was some dedication which I thought came from a John Le Carre novel, "For those who served and stayed silent". I can't find the source now, but that's my spirit. (I am not in the IT area, I am in academia.)
- valand 5y ago"I told you so syndrome" may be a normal thing. I once read a psychological paper talking about "one's willingness to make personal sacrifice for making other people feel remorse and learn when they make mistake" or something along that line (Shame I can't find the link nor remember the exact title) "I told you" is a social sacrifice I suppose.
- moksly 5y agoI’ve found that management and decision making is much more of a social thing than anything else. Which is probably why your “I told you so”’s feel so worthless. I don’t think think quietly making people crash into a wall is the best way to handle it either, but having worked in the same political organisation for a decade I can certainly see why it’s easier to end up in that category. I prefer to drive into the wall with people instead, working at it together, when that’s what is going to happen despite any concerns I have. Usually when you end up being right, people will listen to you more the next time if you’ve stood there with them. It also helps a lot when your prediction turns out to be wrong. When RPA became a big thing in the Danish public sector a few years back I was one of the stronger voices against it in most of our national ERFA networks. When we got the clear message from the top that we were going to do this, however, I jumped right in and helped us chose and build what is now the leading RPA setup in any Danish municipality aside from Copenhagen. I still think RPA is really terrible from a technical perspective, but I can also see the merit in how it’s currently saved us around 90 years worth or manual case-work at the price of a few months of developer- and support-time in total. Because I was quick to jump aboard what I still thought was going to be a sinking ship when it was going to sail no matter what I did or thought, people don’t hold how wrong I was against me but instead lovingly tease me or sometimes cheer me up with other times where I’ve been right. You have to want to do this of course. If your workplace doesn’t have the sort of people you’ll want to drive into a wall with, the your way is probably better than mine.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> When we got the clear message from the top that we were going to do this, however, I jumped right in and helped us chose and build what is now the leading RPA setup in any Danish municipality aside from Copenhagen. That sounds almost exactly like traditional Japanese consensus. Everyone argues for their opinion during the planning meeting, but once The Big Boss does the "chopping motion" with his (it's always a "he") hand, then everyone is expected to fall in line, and commit to the team effort. They actually despise "I told you so." It's not smart to do that, in a Japanese corporation.
- Siira 5y ago
- beckingz 5y agoSometimes people will insist that sticking beans in their nose is absolutely necessary. https://archive.uie.com/brainsparks/2011/07/08/beans-and-noses/ https://archive.uie.com/brainsparks/2011/07/08/beans-and-nos...
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI love that! Thanks!