3 ms·
Google scares you after you download them. And you have to enable the setting. This should be as seamless as using web apps, and permissions dialogues should c
by echelon 5y ago
Google scares you after you download them. And you have to enable the setting.
This should be as seamless as using web apps, and permissions dialogues should come up when the app attempts to use certain device features. (No different than App Store downloads today.)
All of this to say that web-downloaded native apps are not first class on Android. They should be.
- int_19h 5y agoPermission dialogs are very ineffective in desktop OSes, with users effectively being trained to just click through them to "get things done". Is there any research showing that they fare better on mobile?
- echelon 5y agoIf web-based installs were the norm, there would be better security hardening efforts made. Today Apple and Google don't have to care about it. If there reputation was at stake, they would care a great deal. I'm also of the belief that we don't have to be a nanny state. We trust people to pour gasoline, drive death chariots at 70 miles per hour, open lines of credit as teenagers, buy and shoot guns, etc. Why all the ceremony here? I think it serves the owners of the platform more than us.
- natch 5y agoSo they should care about their reputation, but they should also let their platform be known as a place where they allow malware to flourish?
- hulitu 5y ago> If web-based installs were the norm, there would be better security hardening efforts made. Today Apple and Google don't have to care about it. If there reputation was at stake, they would care a great deal. Well, web base installs are the norm. That's how malware and ransomware spreads. The problem with security is that is usually anti features. That't why webbrowsers use the path of least resistance and declare that they are secure, they have containers and isolation etc. And Google with project Zero is playing the good guy. It is all security theater. Security is expensive and no one wants to invest in it because it does not have a clear ROI. > I'm also of the belief that we don't have to be a nanny state. We trust people to pour gasoline, drive death chariots at 70 miles per hour, open lines of credit as teenagers, buy and shoot guns, etc. We do not trust people to buy and shoot guns. > Why all the ceremony here? I think it serves the owners of the platform more than us. Of course it serves only them. Security in android stops when you give apps access to SD card or camera or microfone or phone or contacts. And the fact that Google apps have all this access by default says a lot about how much google is interested in security.
- em-bee 5y agoit's not just an "are you sure?" question, but instructions to go to the settings and enable installing from this app. it's enough to stop my kids from installing apps because they don't know how to set that permission (yet). a simple permission dialog would not have that effect. besides that, permission dialogs are better than nothing. the worst would be apps being installed without me even noticing. just because people tend to ignore them that's no reason to abandon them. what would the alternative be?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> This should be as seamless as using web apps, and permissions dialogues should come up when the app attempts to use certain device features. (No different than App Store downloads today.) Web app sandbox is better than native AFAIK, which is a good reason to add friction (because otherwise you're asking for worms).
- EvilEy3 5y agoIt is more restricted because it has less features, it's not necessarily better.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoWho cares? The point here is that web apps are safer to run than native. Yes, they're resource hogs, yes they're feature-poor, but they are still safer to run than native code, so it's perfectly reasonable that an OS makes it harder to run arbitrary native code than webapps.
- chronogram 5y agoI find the mobile Chrome browser and Android to be very encouraging of installing PWAs. And that it warns you once before installing APKs sounds like reasonable security, like Windows smartscreen and Mac whatsit. My F-Droid apps feel as native as the others.