3 ms·
It's pretty simple. If you start from these two premises : 1- All reporting on Xinjiang is rooted in content from organizations linked one way or another to Am
by sudosysgen 5y ago
It's pretty simple. If you start from these two premises :
1- All reporting on Xinjiang is rooted in content from organizations linked one way or another to American/Western defence industry (ASPI, Zenz, BBC, etc... )
2. These groups have, as their modus operandi, used seemingly neutral and informative outlets over which they have influence in order to shape public opinion to manufacture consent.
From then on its pretty easy to come to those conclusions. It's empirically true that quite a bit of reporting on Xinjiang is false, and it's also true that the US uses the issue of Xinjiang to back actions that have a 0% chance of helping victims of human rights abuses there but that materially improve the American geopolitical solution.
Wether your want to take it as far as xtian did is something that can be disputed. But it's definitely valid to connect the veracity of western claims on geopolitical enemies to US/NATO warmongering.
- zepto 5y ago> If you start from these two premises : Starting from those two premises is the fallacy of affirming the consequent.
- sudosysgen 5y agoNo it's not. Those premises are reasonable and many people hold them. They're not affirming the consequent just because you can draw the conclusion from them. It's actually kind of the point of premises, to draw consequences from them. If you disagree, we can discuss where. But there is no fallacy here.