4 ms·
So, think about this. What if you could ship offenders who reach a threshold (violent felony) and you had a place to ship them to. A big island or large area
by mc32 5y ago
So, think about this. What if you could ship offenders who reach a threshold (violent felony) and you had a place to ship them to. A big island or large area 5000sq mi, let’s say. Let that body set their own rules within that geographic area. How would they organize themselves and mete out justice?
[not to be confused with early Australia or whatever in pop culture].
- bwestergard 5y agoI think there are many reasons this is morally and politically unacceptable. But to name just one practical objection: this would only intensify policing of borders (internal to a state's territory or otherwise). Siberian exiles of Tsarist Russia were quite frequently able to make it back to the urban west. Leon Trotsky is one famous example.
- mc32 5y agoYou could ease concerns by making it a choice. Regular prison with whatever sentence or they can live out their sentence in this area. They’d make the rules they live by. There is no “man”. It’s just them.
- bwestergard 5y agoAt that point, you might as well just have a genuinely rehabilitative prison area of the kind many European countries run. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bast%C3%B8y_Prison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bast%C3%B8y_Prison
- lopatin 5y agoSimilarly Stalin was sent to Siberian prisons/work camps in early life. Every time he managed to talk his way out with the guards. Though unlike Trotsky, he went east afterwards.