3 ms·
It's an 800-word op-ed column. The essence of the form is generalizations, vague trend-spotting, and suggestive questions. You've also deceptively misquoted th
by gojomo 18y ago
It's an 800-word op-ed column. The essence of the form is generalizations, vague trend-spotting, and suggestive questions.
You've also deceptively misquoted the article to make it easier to mock. Brooks' actual question is "What happens if collectivist societies, especially those in Asia, rise economically and come to rival the West?"
There's a lot more nuance to that question than your rephrasing, and Brooks is just as aware of Japan, Singapore, and South Korea as you are.
- astine 18y agoI didn't quote him, I paraphrased him, If the quotation marks put you off, then I'm sorry. However, the answer is the same. 'Collectivist,' Asian societies have risen economically and do rival the West. Even the many of the Communist ones which are collectivist, not due to their Asianess, but due to a certain Western import.
- gaius 18y agoOne of the interesting things about the world is that it has provided a laboratory in which we can actually see. Compare East and West Germany pre-unification. Compare North and South Korea. Compare Cuba and Florida.