4 ms·
The past has given vast & unsustainable water rights to farmers. Asking them to please change, please give up their rights, for free, seems unlikely. I think th
by rektide 5y ago
The past has given vast & unsustainable water rights to farmers. Asking them to please change, please give up their rights, for free, seems unlikely. I think this is somewhat what your second point is saying, but I'm a bit confused about the unlimited part. Even those with limits have vast promises they've been made.
I think eminent domain is necessary. Society has to take back those rights it falsely gave. And I don't think we (society) should be asked to pay current market value for the natural resources we once thought we could give away for free in perpetuity.
I commented on the thread on drought from the other day that this feels like one of those situations where a city hands out a century long parking or traffic enforcement contract, and goes to the bank with some short term money. In this case, the situation feels even more dire & sad[1]; it deeply de-legitimizes the notion of governance at all that such mistakes were made. To continue to demand we accept the mistakes of the past forever to preserve the sense that government can be trusted is a gordian knot of a conundrum, but one we must, imo, slice open.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27449269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27449269
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI think it's basically economics (the allocation of scarce resources that have rival uses). Farmer A may have water rights to B amount of water that let him grow $C worth of alfalfa per year. But if the people of city D would value that water at ten times $C, then they should buy the water rights from farmer A at, say, three times $C, and everybody's good. > To continue to demand we accept the mistakes of the past forever to preserve the sense that government can be trusted is a gordian knot of a conundrum, but one we must, imo, slice open. We do it to preserve the rule of law, which is a really big deal. If it costs more money and effort to do it that way, it's worth it.
- rektide 5y agoThe law was unjust & unfair & gave away the future for nothing. This insistence that the past be able to legislate whatever future it want, and that preservation of that past is absolute, is bogus corrupt & full of shit. I can not begin to state how strongly, how illegitemate it is to tell all future generations they must suffer ancient tyrannies. Some compromise is necessary. This attitude that rule of law satisifies no negotiation is bizarre & I hear it again & again & again & I wish I had some way to express how radically disgusting it is. When it comes to water rights, the rule of law is literally destroying civilization. Yet some people insist these ancient rights must be upheld. The people with water rights have no natural or rightful claim above the rest of society: old society merely granted them a privilege, and said that privilege was eternal, no matter what. I have no respect for that corrupt law, and I have no patience for the attitude that it is a threat to law to uphold that which is literally destroying us. There is some Plato-grade everything-must-be-fixed-forever in-perfect-harmony never-changing horse-shit (see: Open Society and It's Enemies) to insist otherwise.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoJust about everything handed to us by the past can be changed, but there are mechanisms through which you have to do it. Those mechanisms exist, right now, today. Stop whining. Go use them.
- rektide 5y agomaking my case & gathering dissent is part of the process. this place here, HN, is a part modern agora, part of how we the public see & align ourselves with the world & the past. telling me to stop, on the other hand, IS whining. i've done you no injury, no harm, but you are complaining of me & commanding me at the same time. i think you can do better. if you do not like my words, fine. you don't have to. you don't have to change your stance either, you are welcome to it. but to me, it reads of complaint & personal expectations.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYou're the one who came along, ascribing to me opinions that I don't hold, and then insulting those opinions. And then you're telling me that you think I can do better. Maybe you also should? You went on an epic rant about how you have no patience with the existing arrangements because they were made in the past. You may call that "making your case", but it sure sounded whiny to me. And when I tell you that, you tell me that by me pointing that out, I'm whining. Pot, you may be protesting a bit much about the kettle. As for "gathering dissent", the HN guidelines say: > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity. "Gathering dissent" sounds to me like a subset of "ideological battle". And my "go do it", while indeed a command (and perhaps not either clearly or kindly expressed), was saying what the guidelines are saying: Take this somewhere else.
- rektide 5y agoI don't believe I spoke with any ideological or political basis. That you think having an opinion & being upset with the status quo constitutes political or ideological battles is only true in as much as you have continued to make a battle out of my opinion & to rain nastiness upon my stance. You continue being a snipe-ey rules lawyering nasty person to me, & saying things about me & characterizing me, rather than addressing anything I say in a substantial form. This is disheartening. > You went on an epic rant about how you have no patience with the existing arrangements because they were made in the past. You may call that "making your case", but it sure sounded whiny to me. That is not how I would characterize my assessment of the situation. I feel you've stripped out any nuance or respect by simmering it down to such simple words, such overt naked conflict. And I think it's a waste of everyone's time to try to surmise whether it's whining or not, and that we'd both have time better spent trying to engage with each other's stances, rather than pick at one another's character & person with shitty snipey assessments like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]