2 ms·
I'm not sure how valid these charts are - how much of what can be purchased exists across the ages? How do you compare a bag of flour, the cost of a carpenter
by helsinkiandrew 5y ago
I'm not sure how valid these charts are - how much of what can be purchased exists across the ages? How do you compare a bag of flour, the cost of a carpenter to make a table, the wool to make a sweater - with a pop tart, an iPhone and a pair of Nike sneakers?
- extr 5y agoTo look at historical purchasing power, it's possible to normalize to a metric something like "ratio of average yearly income to minimum required for sustenance". Eg, assuming you need 1800 kcal a day, scraps of cloth to serve as clothes, small amount of fuel/electricity, etc. So if average wages were $100/Year in 1700 and you needed $50/Year for bare-minimum sustenance, and today an average wage is $50K/Year, but you only need $15K/Year for bare-minimum sustenance, there is a sense in which purchasing power has gone up. Obviously if you start bringing things like iPhones or pop tarts into it, it becomes entirely subjective, and under certain metrics people today live better than the kings of ancient times simply because we have A/C. But then it becomes more of a philosophical question.
- reedjosh 5y agoKind of need a way to measure peasant level income to total wealth available over time. Over the past several hundred years the 'pie' that is total economic goods and services has grown enormously. However, the share a median income can buy of the pie has shrunk greatly. Inflation vs median income intuitively gives a sense of this while not necessarily being scientific. But then economics is the dismal science.
- fancifalmanima 5y agoIt's also only part of the story. If the median or average income has grown at a larger rate than the decline in value of the dollar, you still come out ahead from the perspective of human living conditions. I'm fairly confident that the median American is living a better life than someone in 1630, or 1730, or 1830, or 1930. In short, from an economic growth perspective -- things have generally worked out. Not that things are perfect, or that I love that anything sitting in my bank is slowly losing value. Just that things have been generally going in a positive direction and I'm personally cool with a slowly devaluing dollar if that means that same general trend continues.