5 ms·
> When converted to the value of one US dollar in 2020, goods and services that cost one dollar in 1700 would cost just over 63 dollars in 2020, this means that
by lolinder 5y ago
> When converted to the value of one US dollar in 2020, goods and services that cost one dollar in 1700 would cost just over 63 dollars in 2020, this means that one dollar in 1700 was worth approximately 63 times more than it is today.
Does anyone know what they mean by saying that the U.S. Dollar was worth X in 1700 (much less 1635) when it didn't even exist until 1792? Are they implicitly converting to the Spanish Dollar, or are they just saying that this is what the dollar would be worth if it were around back then? If the latter, how would you go about calculating this?
They attribute the data before 1913 to Dr. Robert Sahr of Oregon State, but I can only find him going back to 1774 [0].
[0] https://liberalarts.oregonstate.edu/spp/polisci/research/inflation-conversion-factors-convert-dollars-1774-estimated-2024-dollars-recent-year https://liberalarts.oregonstate.edu/spp/polisci/research/inf...
- zamadatix 5y ago> When converted to the value of one US dollar in 2020, goods and services that cost one dollar in 1700 would cost just over 63 dollars in 2020, this means that one dollar in 1700 was worth approximately 63 times more than it is today. This data can be used to calculate how much goods and services from the years shown would cost today, by multiplying the price from then by the number shown in the graph. For example, an item that cost 50 dollars in 1970 would theoretically cost 335.5 US dollars in 2020 (50 x 6.71 = 335.5), although it is important to remember that the prices of individual goods and services inflate at different rates than currency, therefore this graph must only be used as a guide.
- lolinder 5y agoYes, I read that. That explains how to use the graph, but not how they arrived at the numbers on the graph. What methodology did they use to compare prices for goods in U.S. Dollars in 1913 with prices for goods in Spanish Dollars (or pounds sterling, or whatever) in 1635 to come up with an index? This is one of the things I dislike about statista.com. By putting their sources behind a paywall, they create a bunch of graphs that people can throw around the internet, but hide the context necessary to properly interpret them. The misinformation potential is huge.
- paulpauper 5y agoHow about 2000 years ago? Imagine a dynasty that invested just $1 in AD 0 and kept adding to it
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- derbOac 5y agoThere's a discussion of it here: https://www.americanantiquarian.org/proceedings/44517778.pdf https://www.americanantiquarian.org/proceedings/44517778.pdf Not sure if it's the same method, but there they say these kinds of analyses are produced by using known exchange rates for different currencies, and then sort of back-estimating the value of the dollar based on those exchange rates. So if you know the value of the USD in 1792, you can use different exchange rates with existing currencies to retroactively estimate the value of the USD if it had existed. Ideally it seems you'd somehow aggregate over different currency exchange rates; maybe they all produce a unique solution, or maybe that aggregate is done some other way.
- hbrav 5y agoIf you were to do this with a new currency that was created today, that would not giver you a unique solution. e.g. if you said "well Bitcoin started its existence in 2009, and had an exchange rate of X USD = 1 BTC, so before this date we'll use X USD to stand in for 1 BTC", you get a different solution if you change USD to EUR, or GBP, or CAD, etc. because the EUR/USD rate changes over time prior to 2009. But back around the 1700s, were most currencies pegged to precious metals? In which case I think you have a lot less freedom in your solution (I think you're basically choosing between gold and silver).
- derbOac 5y agoI agree it's odd. I could see some kind of legitimate rationale if it were specified clearly, depending on the rationale, but there's some sort of fuzz going on that makes it sketchy. I'm also not sure where the 1635 date comes from -- that implies something meaningful but not necessarily, and what exactly I don't know.
- kd5bjo 5y ago> But back around the 1700s, were most currencies pegged to precious metals? From 1792 to 1853, the US Dollar was pegged to a fixed amount of both gold and silver. It seems reasonable to extrapolate backwards in time using that fixed standard, though the changing relative values of those metals might give you some problems. (According to Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#In_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_standard#In_the_United_St... )
- slg 5y agoWhatever the approach, I'm not sure those 17th century numbers pass the eye test. Does it make sense that pre-industrial revolution purchasing power would be roughly the same as it was at the beginning of the 20th century?
- ghaff 5y agoThat's one problem with trying to compare CPI over long periods. Consumers are buying totally different types and quantities of things with their dollars.
- slg 5y agoExactly, it all seemingly depends on the arbitrary decisions about how we define our basket of goods. For example is it generic "clothing" or an individual outfit of clothing. Individual pieces of clothing cost drastically more pre-industrial revolution. Because of that, people owned a lot less clothes. Therefore purchasing power increased by that metric. However consumers responded to clothes becoming cheaper by expanding their wardrobes. The average person likely owned a lot more clothing by the time the 20th century rolled around. That could mean purchasing power was relatively similar if the metric was generic "clothes". I'm not sure either approach is any more correct than the other.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI was always interested in how much discretionary spending they had - you have to pay electricity or whale oil bill, and have whatever clothing is mininally required to not look homeless - but after all that, what do you have left?
- FredPret 5y agoOn one end of that timeline people were buying buying barrels of whale oil, and on the other end they are subscribing to internet services!
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoIt’s a tough problem. I’m guessing their assumption is that since the dollar was commodity money in that time frame, an ounce of silver was worth the same in 1700 as in 2000. It’s probably not far off.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe dollar was based on silver content (~25g iirc), and I think you can reasonably accurately compare values and inflation based on comparable coins.