5 ms·
Note that if you are just interested in US sales taxes, and only need to collect tax in the ~1/2 of the states that are part of the Streamlines Sales Tax (SST)
by tzs 5y ago
Note that if you are just interested in US sales taxes, and only need to collect tax in the ~1/2 of the states that are part of the Streamlines Sales Tax (SST) project, you can have your tax rate calculation, registration, reporting, and filing all done for free.
The member states of SST have agreed to pay for those services from several tax SaaS companies. (There is one catch: to avail yourself of this, you must collect tax for all SST states, even though you might be below the threshold in some of them).
The companies participating are Avalara, TaxCloud, Sovos, and Accurate Tax.
For small online businesses I suspect that a lot more can take advantage of this than you might expect. Here's a map showing the SST member states [1]. Although it is missing some big states that you probably do a lot of business in (California for instance), a lot of those big states have quite high thresholds for sales or number of transactions before tax kicks in.
Some of the companies that provide the fee SST service will also add non-SST states for a fee. If you only need one or two non-SST states, it will still probably come out cheaper than using Stripe (and will include reporting and filing).
[1] https://www.streamlinedsalestax.org/ https://www.streamlinedsalestax.org/
- teamspirit 5y agoHow quickly my excitement disappeared when I saw that California was not a member. Thanks for the information; I'm sure there are others, like myself, that have no idea such a thing exists.
- tzs 5y agoI'm somewhat baffled by California not being a member. California's threshold below which out of state remote sellers do not have to register, collect, report, or remit sales tax is $500 000/year of sales into California. If I'm a remote seller using the free SST option to handle my taxes in the SST states, and am selling say $300 000/year in California, I will not be collecting any California tax. If they joined SST, I would have to collect California tax even though I'm below the threshold because the deal to get free full service tax handling under SST is that I collect for all SST states. I don't see any downside for California. At the stroke of a pen, they would suddenly be getting tax collected from a ton of remote sellers that fall below the $500 000/year threshold. Same with Texas, which also has a $500 000/year threshold, or New York which is $500 000/year and 100 transactions, or Florida which is $100 000/year, or Illinois which is $100 000/year or 200 transactions.
- gamblor956 5y agoCalifornia is not a member of the SST because it does not currently tax a number of things that are subject to tax under the SST regime. For example, digital goods are taxable in SST states but not in California. Similarly, there are a number of other product categories where CA's taxability classifications do not match the SST's classifications. Generally, the total tax they could collect from remote (non-CA) sellers below the $500k nexus threshold is not worth the effort it would take to change things so that CA could join the SST, and moreover, it would require significant changes by CA sellers. Generally, those same considerations also apply in NY: the cost burden on local sellers to make the change would dwarf any minuscule tax increase from joining the SST.
- spockz 5y agoInteresting. People bemoan that the market in Europe is too splintered and that the whole of the us can be seen as one market. But all these state differences seem to at least indicate that it isn’t that simple.
- germanier 5y agoInterestingly, VAT law is mostly harmonized in the EU and remittance will get even easier starting July where you can declare and pay VAT on cross-border sales to just one entity ("One-Stop-Shop").
- tzs 5y agoThe US could really use some national action on sales taxes. I'd like to see Congress make it so a state can only require remote sellers with no physical presence in the state to collect tax for the state if: 1. Tax rates on remote sales are uniform within a zip code. No more having to deal with "123 Fake Street, Hooterville, 65026" having a different tax rate than "124 Fake Street, Hooterville, 65026". (Worse, I recall finding an example where a tax boundary apparently ran through an office building, so different offices on the same floor had different tax rates!). 2. They adopt a standard for tax classification that will be specified by the Federal government. They don't have to change the classifications used for taxing sellers with a presences in the state, but for remote sellers they have to use the Federal classifications. 3. Rates for remote sales can only change once per quarter, and the data for the quarter must be published one month before the start of the quarter. It must be published on the web, at a URL that requires no registration or fees, in a format specified by the Federal government. The Federal government would maintain a web page that contains links to the state data pages. 4. Sellers can report taxes using a uniform format defined by the Federal government. The format supports reports that cover the taxes for more than one state. The seller can file such a multi-state report with any state that requires remote sellers to collect tax that they owe tax to, and that state will forward the report to the other states it contains data for. The seller can also pay all the tax to that state, and it will transfer the appropriate amounts to the other states. If Congress did this it would make dealing with remote sales tax so much easier.
- kmoriarty 5y agoThis is spot on. It's an interesting program perhaps, but unfortunately a lot of states are missing including California, Texas, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, New York, Massachusetts, South Carolina, and we're not seen any uptake from other states toward adoption either.
- ysavir 5y agoI had no idea this was a thing! You should submit it to HN as its own item.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoInteresting. Why is CO not participating? Looks like every other state is involved to some extent.
- gamblor956 5y agoCO has a very unique sales tax system: every county, city, and special district can set its own rates, and define taxable (or nontaxable) product categories, and determine the taxability of of those product categories, and even apply special (formulaic) discounts for complying with the tax regime. Plus, a number of tax jurisdictions overlap. And this is the simplified system that the state implemented in 2019 to make things easier for remote sellers in a post-Wayfair world. And that doesn't even include the roughly 70 home-rule cities which administer their sales tax separately from the state's "simplified" tax system. For filing purposes, each CO "tax location" is treated as a separate return by Avalara and other sales tax services providers, so the costs can add up very quickly for remote sellers using these services for sales tax reporting compliance: Denver alone has more than two dozen separate "tax locations." Consequently, at my company we use Avalara to compute sales tax for remote sales to CO but file the CO returns ourselves and save several thousand $$$ each month. Luckily, due to Wayfair nexus requirements, CO sales tax compliance only kicks in at 100k or more in gross sales to CO (not including sales to home-rule cities). Because each home-rule city has its own sale tax system, the nexus threshold is independent for each home rule city; the state has advised these cities to set a threshold of $100k to avoid nexus-related litigation that could result in a bright-line rule setting an undesirably high threshold for nexus.
- velcrovan 5y agoBecause Colorado has the most garbage sales tax regime in probably the world.
- Cerium 5y agoBased on my personal experience I would recommend staying away from TaxCloud. When they make mistakes filing for you (and they have) the states will come to you directly with scary letters, TaxCloud won't answer your calls or messages. The only way I was able to sort things out was by getting another states small business advocate to help. TaxCloud also has a habit of changing their fees without notice. Currently they charge an API access fee even for their "free" accounts. Finally, they lock you in by not giving you enough information to cancel all the accounts they started for you in other states but not providing a clear way to cleanly close your account.
- cryptoized 5y agoThanks for the insight, I hope SST get more adaption.... https://www.streamlinedsalestax.org/ https://www.streamlinedsalestax.org/.
- ilikehurdles 5y agoDisappointing that I live in the only non-participating state. Wonder what motivated Colorado to reject this.