3 ms·
Sorry but where is actual scientific content in that paper? I'm concerned with the state of AI. saying that "reinforcement is all you need", when reinforcement
by Barrin92 5y ago
Sorry but where is actual scientific content in that paper? I'm concerned with the state of AI. saying that "reinforcement is all you need", when reinforcement learning is defined as abstract as "agent does something, adapts to environment and rewards, then does another thing" is borderline tautological.
The actual scientific question is, what are the mechanisms that make agents work, what are the fundamental modules within intelligent systems, is there a distinction between digital and biochemical systems, what costs are there in terms of resources and energy to get to a certain level of intelligence, and so on. Real questions with specific answers. For all the advances coming from just upping the amount of data and GPU hours, there is so little progress on trying to have a model of the structures that underpin intelligence.
- zzzzzzzza 5y agoi think part of what they are saying is that your approach is wrong, (e.g. looking for then copying submodules within intelligence won't generalize), trying to answer specific questions won't generalize, but if you train a network with the right potentially hacky series of rewards/rich enough environment you could get a much more general intelligence a new kind of science