4 ms·
>> So this study doesn't have enough statistical power to say how vaccines compare to previous infection. Could be better, could be up to 3 times worse within a
by phkahler 5y ago
>> So this study doesn't have enough statistical power to say how vaccines compare to previous infection. Could be better, could be up to 3 times worse within a high confidence interval.
Could be. But it would be great if they'd just say having had a confirmed case is equivalent to getting the vaccine because several studies have now shown that to be roughly the case. It's also conventional medical wisdom although it varies by virus.
- cbsmith 5y agoUnfortunately, we have reason to believe that over time, the immune defenses from COVID-19 infection seem to decline, particularly in older folks. It'd be great if we had some definitive data on secondary infection rates, but until a lot more people get infected, we just won't have it.
- barney54 5y agoWhat is the evidence that “we have reason to believe that over time, immune defenses from COVID-19 infection seems to decline”?
- astrange 5y agoI think this is another case where improved surveillance is turning up things that, while they look bad, happen with other vaccines and never turn out to be a problem. The same goes for variants, which a lot of people expect to break through vaccines because that's how the flu works, but it doesn't actually seem like they will.
- jkhdigital 5y agoYes, the extreme focus of attention is turning routine and expected medical observations into scary anecdotal news cycles.
- huffmsa 5y agoI keep hearing this, but have yet to see evidence that the elderly are catching second rounds at a high rate.
- garmaine 5y agoBecause there isn’t any. But that is how the aging immune system responds to most other diseases, so we assume the same will be true here.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoNo kidding. It's clear to me that protection at some level is provided following infection - which simply makes sense. You'll notice they say - we don't have enough data. Then data is incomplete. Then we can't really say because study was X / Y / Z. They ignore the MASSIVE difference in your chance of being infected if you are unvaccinated and have not been infected vs many other combos. Just treat folks who've been infected as vaccinated, they can get booster / variant shots with everyone else when the time comes.
- johnchristopher 5y agoI'd like to know the death rate of infected unvaccinated people who get covid again against vaccinated people who get covid and get sick.
- sgt101 5y agoAccording to this study it could be a long time before we know that - I think cov-19 in the presence of a non overwhelmed medical system armed with steroids and oxygen kills less than 2/100 infected folk so getting enough incidents in either of those arms of a trial is going to be hard work.
- iso1210 5y agoThe death rate for certain demographics (especially say over 70s) is far higher than 2-in-100. While some countries have high levels of vaccination - especially in those demographics - most don't. The UK is enterring a third wave, and has a high number of elderly people having been fully (2 shot, mainly AZ) vaccinated. Early indications are that those enterring hospitals now on the whole have not been fully vaccinated.
- benjaminwootton 5y agoAnd for most people under 70, it's way under that, FWIW.
- occamrazor 5y agoThe rough consensus is that an infection is equivalent to a single dose of vaccine. Some countries do not give the second dose to previously infected people.