4 ms·
>Is there a growing sense that our GUI/UI paradigms took a wrong step somewhere in CS history and we've pushed the current UI path as far as it will go? Yes. I
by coldtea 5y ago
>Is there a growing sense that our GUI/UI paradigms took a wrong step somewhere in CS history and we've pushed the current UI path as far as it will go?
Yes. It was called "web UI".
This brought a level of casualness and lack of rigor, that infected native UIs as well.
In the 90s there was a lot of GUI research, including by major companies like Microsoft and Apple, and lots of innovations.
But even more importantly, the standard practices of the main OS makers, favored a uniform look, with clear affordances (e.g. button bevels), and so on. The apex of with would be something like Windows 2000, Mac OS 8, BeOS, NeXT, and the like.
Stuff like "mystery meat navigation", "hamburger menus", "invisible scrollbars", huge padding, buttons that look like text, and so on, including "let's make the whole desktop app interface in the DOM" where post-2000 additions, and not for the better.
- walrus01 5y agothe latest version of xfce4 is what I would call a really clean, no bullshit modern desktop metaphor. I say that as a person who extensively used kde v1 and v2.x and migrated away from it when they started trying to clone windows vista. In some ways xfce4 reminds me a lot of windows 2000.
- coldtea 5y agoYeah, but unfortunately xfce4 just covers the desktop manager + some utility apps part. Most of the apps would be an assortment of (non Xfce) Gnome-inspired GTK, Electron (e.g. Slack, VSCode), custom (Firefox, Chrome, Sublime Text), and/or KDE stuff, each with its own warts and "modern" approaches...
- int_19h 5y agoMATE would probably be closer in terms of its feature set.