2 ms·
> I personally wish it weren't permitted in the first place, but revoking the permit afterwards is the worst possible outcome. Why? It was obvious from the st
by mschuster91 5y ago
> I personally wish it weren't permitted in the first place, but revoking the permit afterwards is the worst possible outcome.
Why?
It was obvious from the start of the planning that this project was at risk from political intervention given the continuous protests and the general political landscape (being blocked by Obama and then unblocked by Trump, with Democrats calling for the reversal of the decision).
It was obvious that long-term political trends are leading towards ecological conservation, that international treaties limit CO2 emissions and that oil consumption will only go downwards given the rise of viable electric car models.
The companies behind Keystone XL accepted this risk, and if they now go bankrupt or face massive losses as a result of not accounting for obvious risks, I don't shed any tears for them. They were aware, never forget that.
- fallingknife 5y agoYou missed some details there. It was approved under the Obama administration before it was rejected by the state department on the vague grounds that it is "not in the national interest." The state department was only involved since it crossed the border with Canada, and for deals with close allies like Canada, this approval is typically a formality. It sets a bad precedent when the government capriciously steps in to block a deal that has been years in the making because of political pressure.
- zbrozek 5y agoThe loss of trust in the finality of approvals is the key thing we should be shedding tears over. It would obviously have been far better not to permit it in the first place. Suppose a big offshore wind project gets underway now and an opposing government wins the next election - now there's precedent to just pull the plug. Or at a much smaller scale, suppose you've just won permission to build a house and a new city council is elected and revokes your permit. How much are you going to trust your government after that? It also widens the door for more forms of corruption. "Shame if that permit were to suddenly evaporate..." If you don't want carbon emissions, tax them to death. Or don't permit projects that produce them. But don't revoke permits of projects you've approved!
- mschuster91 5y ago> If you don't want carbon emissions, tax them to death. Or don't permit projects that produce them. But don't revoke permits of projects you've approved! The thing is: circumstances change, science evolves as new data is discovered. Permits are a human concept, humans can choose to modify and revoke them - but (absent someone inventing 23rd century Starfleet technology) humanity cannot reasonably stop climate change - we're past that point anyway and only doing damage control. Our grandchildren will curse us all for the "but they had a permit!!!" attitude - no matter if it's about climate change or Nestle and almond farmers bleeding water supplies dry!