3 ms·
It's hard not to be sympathetic to those Albertans whose lives will be impacted by this decision. However, for too long Canada has relied on extractive industri
by pseudolus 5y ago
It's hard not to be sympathetic to those Albertans whose lives will be impacted by this decision. However, for too long Canada has relied on extractive industries leading to a mild case of Dutch disease. Perhaps the loss of Keystone will jump-start Alberta's nascent start-up scene and other non-polluting sectors of its economy.
- eloff 5y agoAlberta fundamentally has to shift gears - just like Saudi Arabia. The world will move on from fossil fuels and they had better have a plan to transition. Norway has been handling their fossil fuels remarkably intelligently.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Norway has been handling their fossil fuels remarkably intelligently. How so? Oil production is ticking back up and is higher than any time since about 2010.
- jgon 5y agoNorway is an entire country that has just slightly more people than the province of Alberta, which is to say that is it much smaller than Canada, while having oil reserves equal to or greater than those in Alberta. Alberta should obviously have been more diligent in saving up oil revenues generated, but this ignores the fact that a huge amount of oil revenues generated in Alberta have gone to help the rest of the country develop as well. Roughly 250-300 billion dollars from Alberta has transferred to the rest of the country since Alberta's discovery of oil, which would essentially give funding equivalent to the Norwegian sovereign fund. So when people say "where did all the money go?" the answer is that it went to hospitals in Chicoutimi, roads in Neepawa, schools in Battle Harbor, etc, etc. Trying to compare sovereign Norway with a single province in a confederation is always going to give a skewed view of what Alberta should or should not have done with its resource wealth.
- mnouquet 5y ago> Alberta should obviously have been more diligent in saving up oil revenues generated It was literally all stolen by the Federal government through equalization payment. Can't really blame Alberta here...
- mnouquet 5y ago> Alberta fundamentally has to shift gears - just like Saudi Arabia. The only problem here is that Alberta was forced to give up all its money in equalization payment, and has none left.
- munk-a 5y agoMost of Canada, outside of Alberta, has long transitioned away from extraction dominant industries. There still is a whole bunch of it around - but, in BC it accounts for 5.7% of the economy and in Canada at large all natural resource extraction only accounts for 10% of the economy. The majority of Canada's economy is now service oriented.
- jgon 5y agoThis claim is nominally true, but leaves out a metric boat-load of context, in the classic "the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth" sense. BC only has resource extraction take up 10% of it economy, but it is more dependent on real estate (aka flipping houses) as a percentage of its economy that Alberta is dependent on Oil and Gas. Flipping real estate isn't exactly a great foundation for an economy, but sure it has transitioned away from extraction. Secondly, the majority of Canada's economy is service oriented, but due to the way Canada is structured, the super-majority of the transfer payments that the federal government makes to the various provinces comes from resource extraction generated revenues. The following statements are not meant to be value judgements, they are just simple statements of fact that should give color to the context that is missing from the parent comment. For non-Canadian HN users, in order to guarantee a relatively equal standard of living for Canadian citizens regardless of where they happen to live, the federal government distributes billions of dollars every year to various provinces, taking from the more wealthy provinces and helping shore up the budgets of the less wealthy provinces. These revenues have been generated in overwhelmingly large part by resource extraction, and the service oriented economies of other provinces show 0 possibility of taking up the slack for these revenues should resource extraction end, they simply don't generate enough surplus on a per-capita basis. Without these revenues large portions of Canada would face absolutely devastating cuts to government revenues and thus services, and frankly no government has really put forth any sort of solution to this, outside of larger deficits on a temporary basis. How Canada navigates this difference between its aspirations, a service oriented non-resource economy, and the reality on the ground, an absolute dependence on resource revenues for current quality of life, is probably the biggest question it will face in the 21st Century.
- 5y ago
- mnouquet 5y ago> start-up scene and other non-polluting sectors of its economy Because all modern-day chip are so much environmentally friendly...