34 ms·
This seems like cherry-picking. Quackery doesn't care about regulation (for example, hydroxychloroquine is prescription-only in the US), and shady hucksters ab
by sneak 5y ago
This seems like cherry-picking. Quackery doesn't care about regulation (for example, hydroxychloroquine is prescription-only in the US), and shady hucksters abound in all industries (including ours; look at all the meaningless "threat intelligence" hype).
You could also just as easily look at the situation where poultry practices banned in Europe are the norm everywhere in the single-hand-countable poultry producers in the US, or the "regulation" they apply to tobacco products (which kill 7x more than opiates in the USA). It's a farce.
The FDA isn't doing what they ostensibly exist to do, and they are doing a whole bunch of stuff they're not. It's the worst of both worlds.
- tptacek 5y agoThe supplements market is literally the largest unregulated market for pharmaceuticals. I'm not sure how it could be cherry-picked.
- sneak 5y agoThe supplements market is quite tiny ($36bn) compared to the "unregulated market for pharmaceuticals" that most people mean by that phrase ($150bn+). For me and many, many others, that market serves us far better than the regulated one. You're cherry-picking supplements quackery and hucksterism out of the 6x larger "unregulated drugs" market on Earth, which exists despite insanely harsh penalties prohibiting it. It would likely be much larger if not illegal.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not sure I understand your argument. The supplements market is an even bigger fraction of the pharmaceuticals market than I thought, so I'm even more convinced of my point now. But, again: the literal point of the supplements market is to function the way you suggest the pharmaceuticals market should. I think that we should rather regulate the remaining $36B in supplements out of existence.