3 ms·
> My point is that this isn't even an interesting conversation to have. Your desktop can outperform a chip that runs an iPad? Cool story bro. The desktop I'm c
by smoldesu 5y ago
> My point is that this isn't even an interesting conversation to have. Your desktop can outperform a chip that runs an iPad? Cool story bro.
The desktop I'm comparing it to is 7 years old and cost $600 new. You can't even buy an M1 iPad for that price today.
> Their announcement explicitly said "when it comes to low power silicon."
Which is an arbitrary goalpost that means nothing. The M1 uses 7w at full tilt, does that mean we can compare it to an AMD 5800u running at the same wattage? It's a nothingburger, and that's why Apple doesn't use that zinger anywhere else in their marketing material.
> Why should they be forced to compare their integrated graphics to laptops with dedicated graphics?
Because that's what you can buy for $1000. That's the performance standard. If Apple wanted the M1 to be compared to machines with integrated graphics, they should have released a computer at that price point.
> Apple very clearly laid out their design goals with the M1: supremacy at performance per watt.
Sure, they have it. But I frankly don't care, and I have a hard time believing that other people do too. Performance-per-watt is Apple's neat way of giving performance a denominator, because they simply can't compete with the rest of the industry wholesale. It's something they've done over and over, insisting on pointless metrics like thinness and beauty to measure a product of objective capability. The datacenter market is looking at the M1 and laughing. Unless your business was already Mac-based, it's not like enterprise customers are going to be interested in beta-testing Apple's new hardware either. Honestly, I'm more impressed with Apple's social engineering than hardware engineering here.
- whynotminot 5y ago> The desktop I'm comparing it to is 7 years old and cost $600 new. You can't even buy an M1 iPad for that price today. Which desktop is this with what components? What's the metric you're comparing? Show me the benchmarks. This still feels like the world's dumbest comparison but hey I'm at least curious now. > Which is an arbitrary goalpost that means nothing. But it's the goalpost they very clearly set--you're the one who either missed it or willfully chooses to ignore it, which means you're the one being misleading, not them. > Because that's what you can buy for $1000. That's the performance standard. If Apple wanted the M1 to be compared to machines with integrated graphics, they should have released a computer at that price point A pure price comparison on its own is missing so many relevant factors and you know it. You can also buy a desktop that outperforms a smartphone that costs the same. Is that a fair comparison? How much energy do these machines consume, what's their battery life under load, how much do they weigh, etc etc. I don't just walk into Best Buy and say "here's a $1,000 bring me the thing with the best Geek Bench score, no other criteria." >The datacenter market is looking at the M1 and laughing What are you even talking about now. Since when was the datacenter in the design goals for the M1. >But I frankly don't care, and I have a hard time believing that other people do too No one cares about battery life or the weight of their laptop? This is news to me. I have a feeling it's news to all the people who buy ultrabooks, too. >Performance-per-watt is Apple's neat way of giving performance a denominator, because they simply can't compete with the rest of the industry wholesale. Because they're not trying to outcompete the entire industry in every form factor with the M1, since the goal is to provide stellar performance while still achieving efficiency that enables small form factor designs. You are exhausting with this "willfully missing the whole point" thing. Again, they haven't even released the parts that are actually meant to compete at the higher wattages you're trying to compare against the M1. I'll make an analogy--maybe it'll help. Car Company A just came out with a brand new sedan with industry best Miles Per Gallon. And beyond just the MPG rating, it can actually tow some pretty heavy loads, too! Heavier than other sedans in its weight class. Impressive stuff. You're the guy with the F-350 dually pumping his chest saying "mine can still tow more!"
- smoldesu 5y ago> You're the guy with the F-350 dually pumping his chest saying "mine can still tow more!" You're the guy getting downvoted for acting like a child when everyone disagrees with you. I'm done here.
- whynotminot 5y agoAh, so we're talking the ball and going home now. Who is this everyone you speak of?
- dang 5y agoPlease don't respond to someone breaking the site guidelines by breaking them yourself. I know that's hard when you're feeling provoked, but it only makes this place even worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 5y agoYou broke the site guidelines repeatedly in this thread. That's not cool. Would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and make your substantive points respectfully in the future? That means no name-calling, no personal attacks, and no swipes.