4 ms·
> If I sell my house for more than I paid for it, it's zero sum since someone simply provided me that money. No transaction between rational individuals is eve
by dragontamer 5y ago
> If I sell my house for more than I paid for it, it's zero sum since someone simply provided me that money.
No transaction between rational individuals is ever zero-sum.
If Bob values a house at $300,000 and Alice values the house at $300,000, the house will __never__ be sold. Because by the time transaction fees come about, Bob would have lost money in the transaction.
In reality, Bob values the house at $250,000, and Alice is happy to buy at $350,000. Maybe some negotiations happen, and after transaction fees, Bob receives $270,000 while Alice pays $330,000 (both happy), with the Banks / Real Estate agents pocketing the $60,000 spread.
-------
This is called the Bid-Ask spread, and its always, always, always non-zero. Stocks have bid-ask spreads of a penny, but Pokemon Cards, Houses, Lumber, etc. etc. all have a spread in reality. There's never one price for things, there's a buyer's price vs a seller's price, the bid and the ask.
------
The difference in the bid-ask spread gives you an idea of how much value any transaction created. If Bob was willing to sell the house for $270,000 and Alice was willing to buy the house for $330,000, then there was at LEAST $60,000 of value created by the transaction.
- bko 5y agoRight, I was using "zero sum" by the author's naive definition to show that it doesn't make sense. My argument is that all voluntary trade has to be positive sum to both parties
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sremani 5y agoI do not think home buying is exactly this. It's much emotional and sometimes both parties involved are green - this may describe a transaction between two veteran RE investors.
- klipt 5y agoHow do you distinguish between true value creation and simple asset inflation? Low interest rates cause soaring asset prices, which can create an illusion of "value creation", but I don't see it actually increasing the value much.
- nostrademons 5y agoLow interest rates actually do increase preferences (and hence value) for cash-generating assets. The competition (keeping the money in risk-free assets, usually expressed as T-bills) becomes less valuable, which means that other assets become relatively more valuable. There are a bunch of results from both behavioral economics and psychology that suggest humans can't actually determine absolute value, and can only determine relative value, comparing two alternatives against each other. This also gets at the paradox behind a lot of our intuitive notions of "value creation". If a person buys high and sells low, taking a loss, they've lost value. Or have they? At the time they made the first transaction, they valued the new asset higher; at the time they made the second one, they valued it lower. As my therapist used to say, "The past and the future don't actually exist; there is only the present." I've seen writers try to resolve the paradox by introducing the idea of "time preferences" or "future selves". You, right now, are not the same person you will be in the future. You can express compassion for your future self by taking action - like delaying gratification, investing in personal development, or saving money - that benefits your future self. The degree to which people preference their future self over their present self is culturally dependent, which is why certain ethnic groups and social classes tend to amass large amounts of wealth while others are perpetually living on the edge of subsistence. The rate of interest is a quantitative measure of how much people preference their future self over their present.
- klipt 5y ago> If a person buys high and sells low, taking a loss, they've lost value. Or have they? At the time they made the first transaction, they valued the new asset higher; at the time they made the second one, they valued it lower. Right, it seemed like a good idea at the time. But they're experiencing regret because an alternate past action (just holding cash, or buying a better performing asset) would have given them more value now. Of course you can regret any suboptimal action (anything less optimal than buying the best performing asset), but that's not most people's baseline. I think the baseline for most people is holding cash, hence they mostly feel regret when their assets' cash value decreases. Unless interest rates stay low forever, at some point the asset inflation they cause has to deflate.
- CrazyStat 5y ago>This is called the Bid-Ask spread, and its always, always, always non-zero. Stocks have bid-ask spreads of a penny, but Pokemon Cards, Houses, Lumber, etc. etc. all have a spread in reality. There's never one price for things, there's a buyer's price vs a seller's price, the bid and the ask. If a bid-ask spread can be positive (as in a stock where the bid is lower than the ask) and can be negative (as in your house example where the bid is higher than the ask), why can't it be zero? It seems like you're conflating the bid-ask spread with consumer/producer surplus that arises from being willing to buy/sell at prices higher/lower than the market clearing price.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If a bid-ask spread can be positive (as in a stock where the bid is lower than the ask) and can be negative (as in your house example where the bid is higher than the ask), why can't it be zero? It can be, and indeed the Micro 101 model is that in ideal conditions it will be for an infinitesimal slice of transactions that actually take place, as all potential transactions with a 0-or-higher bid-ask spread will occur, but that the average across the market of all voluntary transactions will always be positive.
- CrazyStat 5y ago>as all potential transactions with a 0-or-higher bid-ask spread will occur, bid-ask spread isn't a property of transactions, it's a property of markets. Transactions will occur when someone is willing to pay at least as much as a supplier is charging. The bid-ask spread is how much less the highest bidder is willing to pay than the lowest seller is asking. It's a measure of how far apart buyers and sellers are from making a transaction, at a moment of time in a market.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> bid-ask spread isn't a property of transactions, it's a property of markets The upthread poste by dragontamer which introduced it seemed to ascribe it specifically to particular transactions, and I responded to what waa described in that post, viewing terminological minutiae as less interesting than the concept being discussed for which there seemed adequate clarity in context.
- sedachv 5y ago> then there was at LEAST $60,000 of value created by the transaction. That is not value creation, that is wealth transfer from Alice to Bob. Alice has to earn that excess $60,000 through labor, or exploiting labor.
- whiddershins 5y agoUntrue. This is a huge misconception. Value could have increased for many reasons having nothing to do with labor effectuated by either party. The neighborhood might have changed, and now there are more restaurants. Or maybe it’s just considered more fashionable for intangible reasons. The house could be on the beach, and Alice has decided to take up surfing, so values the location more than Bob ever did in the past. And so on. There can be an almost infinite combination of reasons why Alice may find more value in the property than Bob. Edit: my previous version of this comment had Alice and Bob reversed.
- dragontamer 5y agoOld retired couple have a 6-bedroom house for their former 4-kids (+masters bedroom + guest bedroom). All their kids have moved out, and they're tired of vacuuming so many empty rooms. They want to move to a retirement community. New up-and-coming couple not only have 4-kids, but one more is on the way. They suddenly got an opportunity to work in... Chicago (or insert any other city here), and are looking for a new home to raise their kids in. ----------- The old-couple will likely be willing to sell the house below market value, while the younger couple may be stressed out and otherwise willing to pay above market value. Clearly, value will be created as the new couple buys the home from the old couple. The majority of transactions between rational individuals are of this nature. The only detail remaining is how to proceed with negotiations, but assuming they're rational, the two sides will come to a price point that's favorable to both sides.
- escape_goat 5y agoI value HN for these moments in which someone lucidly debunks an abstraction and undoes the epistemic closure that it had performed. Attempting to articulate my thanks brought to my attention this general idea, that all abstractions are [perhaps I should say 'also'] epistemic closures, so thank you twice.
- corey_moncure 5y agoIn your example, the bid is 350K and the ask is 250K; this is not like a bid-ask spread in a regulated market, in which the bid is by definition lower than the ask, and any bids that exceed the ask take the ask off the books at exactly the ask price. What you are describing is more like arbitrage, and it creates no value, but instead exploits inefficient markets, disparate regulatory environments, or unequal access to markets.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If Bob was willing to sell the house for $270,000 and Alice was willing to buy the house for $330,000, then there was at LEAST $60,000 of value created by the transaction. Where each participants marginal utility function is represented by their name, and P is the actual transaction price, there is exactly Bob(P-$270k) + Alice($330k-P) value created. Calling this “at least $60k value” is wrong, and even calling it “$60k value” ignores the fact that value of $ is no more constant across different market participants than any other item, and that the benefits accrue in particular places.