5 ms·
TFA talks about agriculture being the biggest drain on California's water supply--I'm always disappointed that California (probably the most left-leaning state
by throwaway894345 5y ago
TFA talks about agriculture being the biggest drain on California's water supply--I'm always disappointed that California (probably the most left-leaning state in the country) can't pass sane environmental policies... I can empathize with the impulse to defer restrictions on carbon emissions--carbon is a little intangible and even if California goes to zero co2 it is still impacted by the rest of the world's carbon policy. But water? Every Californian is impacted by the droughts and how other states or nations manage their water has little bearing on California's water supply (of course California's drought is a product of global co2 emissions but I strongly suspect California could have plenty of water if it was managed sustainably).
- smallnamespace 5y agoIt’s not that simple. Water rights in California are complex, often dating back to the Gold Rush era. It’s based on ‘first come first serve’ - the first owner to take a certain amount of water from a waterway can continue to do so. Directly modifying those rights would take a long time and be challenged in the courts. Also, the Central Valley is full of poor farmers who have already been badly affected by recent drought (just drive down there to look at the billboards), so restricting agricultural usage would be another nail in the coffin for their livelihoods.
- throwaway894345 5y agoSubsidize the farmers' losses and overhaul the water rights (deal with legal challenges later doesn't make the problem go away). Eminent domain as necessary. My family has farmed for centuries, so I sympathize, but sustainability is paramount.
- kec 5y agoCalifornia sold rights to pump water to farmers a century ago. The only way to legally undo that is to use eminent domain to purchase those rights back. Given how productive and valuable the farm land is and how scarce water is those rights are now absurdly expensive… it’s an intractable problem.
- rektide 5y agothis is like one of those cities that sells a century long parking enforcement contact to pay the budget today. it's so so so far watching some misgovernance today be unammendable for a series of generations. personally I feel like there has to be some way to reassess. simply letting ancient decisions hold in pepetuity is not acceptable.
- xeromal 5y ago> simply letting ancient decisions hold in pepetuity is not acceptable. If ancient rights were ignored, it would shake the confidence in governments which could have unintended consequences.
- throwaway894345 5y agoAt worst it would make people think "wow, I can't trust the government to uphold agreements 100+ years out into the future if some information comes along to suggest that they shouldn't be upheld", which seems like... exactly what the public should think?
- xeromal 5y agoIf you're an american, what about the bill of rights, the right to a jury, the right to free speech, etc. Are those ancient agreements acceptable?
- twiddling 5y agoonly if the "wrong" people are in power /s
- throwaway894345 5y agoOf course I never said anything was “unacceptable” by virtue of its age.
- rektide 5y ago
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoWhy not tax agricultural use, and dwelling use of water above its zoned capacity at the cost to desalinate? I’ll gladly pay that premium for my Californian lettuce while the farms pack up shop and move somewhere sustainable and less expensive.
- throwaway894345 5y agoSeems like that would leave farmers left holding the bag for California's decades of mismanagement. If you subsidize the farmers then this system would work, but I suspect there are simpler ways to achieve the same ends. Notably, I don't think there will be enough people willing to pay the premium for California lettuce to make up for loss of volume, and I can't imagine California farmers packing up and moving across the country (it's particularly cruel to require them to uproot from their families, communities, etc). Seems like it would be better to pay them to farm a crop that is less water intensive or something.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoProblems created by mismanagement tend to have solutions that are hard to swallow. The sooner we swallow the pill the better off we’ll all be.