5 ms·
The idea that "normal people" will be able to use bitcoin at all without getting their private keys stolen is laughable. Think of how often online bank account
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
The idea that "normal people" will be able to use bitcoin at all without getting their private keys stolen is laughable.
Think of how often online bank accounts get hacked in the US, except the difference now is that your money is gone, permanently.
- acdha 5y ago… and the people who made that possible for the hacker will laugh at you and say it's your fault rather than admitting that the system they sold you is fragile.
- mistercheph 5y agoBut there is a fundamental difference in that you never need to identify yourself to anyone ever: unlike our present banks and institutions where "We will never ask you for your password" is a statement meant with 30 conditionals attached to it, and so is "Don't give out your social security number." Really grandma, never give anyone your private key, ever, and only write it down with pen and paper, never on the computer.
- janeroe 5y ago> The idea that "normal people" will be able to use bitcoin at all ... is laughable. The idea that "normal people" will be able to use cash at all is laughable. The idea that "normal people" will be able to use gold coins at all is laughable. And yet, many use (or used to) and don't need a mommy state to tell them what to do.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI'm all for getting the government out - but cash or gold is way easier to use. If you have a political problem, you need to solve it politically. You can't hack it with a technical solution or politicians and their rich friends will just find a way to use it against you (like it's happening with btc, enjoy limitless tracking and the rich elite profiting from btc as much (if not more) than you) or ban it (like it happened to e-gold).
- G3rn0ti 5y agoWell, the concept of holding cash and gold at home is easier than managing a private key. But as soon as you want your money to work i.e. earn interests or invest it, crypto currencies are easier to work with. I mean, you can literally deposit and earn interest by touching a button inside your Coinbase wallet, right now. Regarding your second argument: Change in the financial system does not happen by itself. You need severe pressure. DeFi has a huge potential to put pressure on the traditional financial markets to make them more accessible to the poor and limit their excesses (monetary inflation). The government could of course “ban” Bitcoin and DeFi. But since they are decentralized it can’t make them really disappear — only more cumbersome to get into (and out of), for example, by closing down centralized exchanges. But the government can’t really prevent you to meet a “dealer” cashing in/out on your cryptos.
- acdha 5y ago> But the government can’t really prevent you to meet a “dealer” cashing in/out on your cryptos. If that “dealer” doesn’t report your transactions under KYC or either of you don’t pay taxes, you’ll get a hard reminder that governments can and routinely do prevent things like this. It’s especially risky to break those laws with cryptocurrencies because you’re leaving a full irrepudiable history of every transaction so when they bust your dealer they get _every_ transaction, not just the one that was caught, and that’s for everyone they’ve dealt with — and since those transactions are all by definition illegal, they have both grounds to investigate and an easy lever to pressure each person to turn in bigger players in exchange for leniency.
- reedjosh 5y ago> you need to solve it politically. And what do you do when politics are fully captured by corporate and oligarchical interests? The majority of bitcoiners see no way out of our current political system. The dollar underpins the US hegemony. Bitcoin wouldn't be necessary if the government would allow alternative currencies, but until bitcoin, it had squashed numerous attempts at alternatives. So to say that we need to solve it politically misses the point. Bitcoin is a solution to solve what is seen as a political mess. Further, politics is just non-violent war. This _is_ a political method. > their rich friends will just find a way to use it against you I don't entirely disagree. I see bitcoin as a start. The lightning network already brings some anonymity to transactions, but it could be made to do better. Monero (XMR) is a privacy based crypto that already does so and can currently do 1500tps on chain (BTC does ~7). Crypto is war against oligarchs motivated by failed traditional politics. Monero and other techs like decentralized exchanges are a step up in weaponry of this war.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wraptile 5y agoHow do you think bank accounts get hacked? It's much easier to yank a password/credit card number people use daily. The benefit of private key is you only need to use it once. Then store it away in a safe or _bank_. More UX will develop over time as adoption grows. We already have hardware wallets that even babies could use. Finally you somehow imply that FIAT theft doesn't happen. Even in recent modern history people have lost all their savings in a snap be it their house burning down, colleague stealing everything or even your bank going under.
- bun_at_work 5y ago> or even your bank going under. FDIC insurance prevents your money from being lost in this case, no? Also, it's a bit ridiculous to think that private keys won't be stolen because you can just store it away in a safe or bank or whatever. People are susceptible to all sorts of scams and this private key won't be a panacea for human stupidity or ignorance.
- KingOfCoders 5y ago"More UX will develop over time as adoption grows. We already have hardware wallets that even babies could use." The difference is this: If people have a hardware wallet they use digitally they think it's like a bank account on their phone. They do not realize that with that wallet if the wallet is gone so is the money. Wheras if the phone is gone, nothing happens to their money.
- tiku 5y agoI don't think they have to use it like we use it..