2 ms·
Mr Hanson's been posting excellent arguments for a while that amount to "there might be life other than ours," and its increasingly reminding me of arguments ov
by h2odragon 5y ago
Mr Hanson's been posting excellent arguments for a while that amount to "there might be life other than ours," and its increasingly reminding me of arguments over religion. I agree with him, and am enjoying his logic and reason, but I think he's arguing against faith here.
Either one is open to the idea that Earth life is not alone, or one isn't; and Reason alone isn't a big enough engine to pull one over the hump to the other side.
I wonder what the "earth is unique" folks will do if faced with proofs; declare war or declare themselves slaves? I doubt they'll be able to handle "peaceful coexistence," which I'd say is a damned good reason for the aliens to stay hidden.
- user-the-name 5y agoWhat the hell?
- simonh 5y agoIt's entirely possible to believe that alien life elsewhere in the universe is possible or even likely, but to be extremely skeptical of supposed UFO sightings.
- h2odragon 5y agoIndeed; but having seen the comments and counter-arguments Hanson keeps drawing, I'd say thats not a common position. I see the split as "earth life is only life"; but that's not a great way of expressing it... Better might be "known life is all life" or "all life is known". My particular peculiar kink in this discussion is that I think there's whole orders of life and modes of being, on this planet, that we have at most barely perceived and roughly imagined. So I get to piss everybody off.
- cinquemb 5y ago> So I get to piss everybody off. Not me, totally on board with whole modes of being and life that we are unaware of and could possibly be unable to perceive at the present moment, even on this planet. Very interested in models to help explore/experiment this space rather than those that don't allow to knowledge to be built upon for future proofs or falsification.