3 ms·
I'll note that the actual title is (now?) "The Political Myth of the Driverless Tube Train" not merely "The Myth of the Driverless Tube Train" And I'm sure tha
by tialaramex 5y ago
I'll note that the actual title is (now?) "The Political Myth of the Driverless Tube Train" not merely "The Myth of the Driverless Tube Train"
And I'm sure that as a claim about politics "myth" may feel about right, but it clearly doesn't work as a technical claim and the article seems to hedge about whether that's what it wants to say.
It pokes Boris, former mayor (a role for which I felt he was well suited) and present Prime Minister (a role in which he's incapable) which is politics, but then it also talks about Grades of Automation, rolling stock upgrades, signalling, and Platform Edge Doors, which are technology not politics.
The sort of contradictions shown are effective for making Boris look foolish (compare Thatcher's pun "You Turn if you want to. The Lady's Not For Turning" to Boris having difficulty remembering what he answered on the same question yesterday...) but they have the reverse effect on matters of fact.
For example, we're reminded repeatedly that the London Underground is very old. But then we're also told, for a different reason, that the Docklands Light Railway is old too. A GoA 3 system, right there in London, operating very safely for decades. Complexity, we're told, is the enemy of automation, but the DLR has only become more complex, adding more branches, longer trains, newer service patterns.
Of course automation of the London Underground is also very old, it had one of the first GoA 2 automated railways in the world. When I was a child the Tube still had guards. If you're a New Yorker this probably seems unremarkable, but that guard is completely unnecessary in ordinary service there's barely enough work for a driver, let alone also needing a guard, and this role was abolished in the London Underground last century.
Safety considerations will make GoA 4 operation of the Deep Tube very difficult to deliver cost effectively in my lifetime. But in practice the objections to automation aren't about some hypothetical unsafe GoA 4 proposal, they're mostly about trying to ensure the RMT retains power in the capital by delaying real, practical projects that would mean London doesn't need so many of their extremely well compensated members.
Turnham Green is a particular red herring. If you've used Turnham Green you may not even be aware that Picadilly trains stop there, because in practice for most purposes they don't. They pass through but most don't stop. A future upgrade might make it practical to have all Picadilly trains once again stop at Turnham Green some day. Or not. Hardly the sort of show-stopper it's presented as in this piece.
In other places where there could be a clash, Selective Door Operation might resolve it. SDO is already used extensively on the London Underground for S-stock.
- vidarh 5y agoThe point of bringing up the technical issues is not that they are unsurmountable, but that they require political will to fund upgrades. The RMT would be easy enough to deal with if there was political will to offer them a suitably lucrative agreement for their present drivers to accept that their numbers will steadily decline.