5 ms·
>One of the billionaires mentioned in this article objected, arguing that publishing personal tax information is a violation of privacy. We have concluded that
by mc32 5y ago
>One of the billionaires mentioned in this article objected, arguing that publishing personal tax information is a violation of privacy. We have concluded that the public interest in knowing this information at this pivotal moment outweighs that legitimate concern
I don't see why they couldn't have anonymized the data [bracketed] and have the same impact. Exact figures are less relevant than providing a picture of what's going on. I think the only reason is to doxx and "shame" or whatever unrelated rationale they have.
And why isn't Twitter suspending their account for doxxing --which they appear to apply unevenly but usually not levelled against birds of a feather.
- 3np 5y agoThese billionaires are significant public people enough that this absolutely falls in the public interest enough to warrant disclosing their identities. Same with politicians. There is legal precedence for this and the norm in journalism.
- mc32 5y agoWhat? Who says so? A politician politicking or a person trading on their looks or public stage persona certainly can expect some invasion of privacy, but even they don’t deserve illegal means of information gathering[1] even less a person just because they happen to be billionaires. “Norms” don’t define things as right. I’m pretty sure we can think of some dark examples. [1]I think I read about something called “The Watergate Scandal” about illegal gathering of information...
- Uehreka 5y agoElon Musk isn’t trading on his public stage persona? That aside, I guess I just don’t have much sympathy. If certain “rules” are gonna apply to billionaires and not normal people, that seems fine by me. It might seem “biased” or “unfair” to some people, but hey: Who ever said we were operating in a “fair” context to begin with? Sure this kind of bias could be turned against more vulnerable people, it already is, it’s about time it got turned against the people at the top.
- Chris2048 5y ago> certainly can expect some invasion of privacy On certain public things, yes. On illegally obtained private finance info - no.
- wmf 5y agoAs Arnold says, this stuff has been known for years or decades but it has had little or no impact. It's well known that specific cases are more persuasive than generalities, so it looks like ProPublica is trying to use that effect to spark more discussion about wealth taxes. Edit: I don't agree with what ProPublica is doing here, but I can understand how the ends might justify the means from their perspective.
- mc32 5y agoI dunno. I don’t think it’s right, if the person has not done something illegal. What’s next, some news org wants Biden out, they don’t have a legit source, but a foreign source has dirt on him, now that’s cool cuz they want to change public opinion of Biden? Was the pearl clutching around Biden’s son’s laptop material being illegally obtained just a flimsy excuse? [uh oh, it’s doxxing, it’s doxxing... suspend their Twitter, Jack are you listening?]
- zorpner 5y agoIt's not possible to be a moral billionaire. As @anoncake phrased it on HN previously -- since wealth has diminishing marginal utility, wealth transfer programs are inherently positive-sum -- and thus, accumulation of wealth so far beyond human need is negative-sum. It's bad for the world, and everyone in it. No system of ethics or morality that permits billionaires (obviously, in the context of current poverty thresholds) is valid.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- savingsPossible 5y agoYou are equating morality with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utilitarianism. With "optimizing the integral of happiness" You can be a perfectly moral denteologian (that is, a person that believes in moral rules, not in moral objective functions) and be a billionaire. A second possibility: you can be a utilitarian, and believe that positive sum trades should always be taken (untenable position as this is (1)) and think you are taking one such trade. That is the claim Elon Musk seems to be making: This money today will save human lifes (electric cars reducing climate change) and increase the future number of lifes worth living in the cosmos (spacex) (1) On the untenability and self-destructiveness of "always take positive sum choices, even if they harm you" 1) living an American middle class life while children starve might be similarly morally reprehensible 2) Not killing oneself and donating ones organs (saves what? 10 lives?) might be similarly morally reprehensible
- idiotbureaucrat 5y agoAs someone who works in the field (government not journalism) with similar data (not IRS data) and has watched others have to implement various privacy laws (including the same federal ones the IRS has to follow on the matter), there are also requirements on the minimum number of data-points when releasing information. For instance, an aggregate number of only 10 data-points is enough for people inside those 10 data-points to band together and out the real information of the remaining people through collective action, as an example. There are thousands of similar contingencies planned for. So if you publish this data redacted, it's still a violation of the privacy laws because you can figure out easily who is whom since there are only a few billionaires and there's enough information provided to narrow down people's identity by looking at public information. As for Twitter or whatever, I believe the law technically was violated only by the person who handed the data to the journalists. After that the journalists can't be held accountable unless they aided in some way in obtaining or they directly requested the data from the individual or group or whomever it was that did this. Honestly, though, this is why people in these positions are held to extremely high standards and it ends up being frustrating when others fall through like this. It's too easy to occur, and these roles are rarely compensated well or have any "backup" for technical tasks since it's all based on who organizations trust, so they can't hire anyone to help and we end up thinly spread. Add a small dash of political or financial incentive and suddenly the data you have been working to design to protect from Russian hackers becomes technologically meaningless when someone just leaks it who has direct access. I'm surprised there aren't more of these happening given the dire straits many of us are in, out in the wild-west on our own with nobody to even talk to about it and nobody willing to work in government (or to not be assumed to be trustworthy enough to have access).