5 ms·
Does anyone know who the author, "Jeremy Arnold" is, and what the "Save Journalism Committee" is and who backs them? Their about page doesn't say who they are:
by wolverine876 5y ago
Does anyone know who the author, "Jeremy Arnold" is, and what the "Save Journalism Committee" is and who backs them? Their about page doesn't say who they are:
https://savingjournalism.substack.com/p/what-this-newsletter-is-about https://savingjournalism.substack.com/p/what-this-newsletter...
Also, why should I or do you trust them over ProPublica? These ranting-style articles are written as if the author possesses the Truth, but analogous to the XKCD about technical standards, all we have is one more point of view.
To me, at this point in Internet history, the ranting, ridiculing style is a strong negative signal. Also, criticism of Silicon Valley billionaires seems to draw responses that try to discredit the news media. (I always wonder: Where then do they get news?)
[Edited slightly for politeness.]
- jeremy_arnold 5y agoOP here. Happy to answer direct questions as you have them. It's a self-funded project. As for trust, I pay bounties for corrections for a reason. And I keep a public list of all past bounties paid. Readers can review and decide how much to trust accordingly.
- wolverine876 5y agoWelcome! Thanks for dropping in. Sorry to grill you when we just met, but what is your background, if you are willing to share publicly (I understand if not)? I just like to know who I am reading, especially on the Internets!
- jeremy_arnold 5y agoGrilling is cool. TLDR is I'm a copywriter turned comms consultant. I work mostly with tech companies. My interest in journalism review came just from years of diving into stories on topics I knew and finding them grotesquely misrepresented. This then kicked up a gear when I wrote about Elon Musk and the Thai cave rescue in 2018 and had a bunch of newspapers/journalists shit on my work. I wrote an exhaustive rebuttal to all their points (and offered them money for any mistakes they could find) and they just didn't read it. I came to realize that they have the privilege of just never having to engage with criticism no matter how rendered. So I started my substack to effectively pre-publish chapters of a book I'm writing with a list of examples of really bad journalism from top outlets. Then going to segue from that to my own journalism-esque platform to put my money where my mouth is a far as building a news org with better incentives and more accountability.
- dky45 5y agoThey didn’t engage with your criticism. Resist the temptation to extrapolate that to conclusions beyond yourself. The idea that as a profession journalists don’t engage with criticism is so demonstrably false it’s absurd. The entire editorial process is engaging with criticism, and it very often comes from outside the newsroom. On a story of this magnitude, that criticism is invited as a matter of policy before publishing (it’s called red teaming). Quite often, that process leads to rereporting, sometimes by another group. You seem to have emotionally reacted to criticism of your own work (which is par for journalism) by declaring that journalism doesn’t get it and needs to be “saved” (from who?). I’m concerned by your personification of a bad experience and the malevolence you’re ascribing to an entire profession as a result, while on the way to sticking your fingers in the same pie. You are coming across as an unreliable narrator in several ways. Even beyond that, you’re going up against ProPublica, not Daily Mail, and it’s very clear from your piece (which I read end to end) that you dove into it in bad faith looking for your intended outcome. It is this comment alone that convinces me you will fail, because you don’t understand why you weren’t engaged and why a lengthy rebuttal to incoming was a waste of your time. You seem to have a chip on your shoulder based on writing about Elon and the Thai thing and not having it go as you’d like which, in the grand scheme of things, matters precisely zero. That you offered money to those journalists as part of that process simply reassures me that you were blocked in their email because that is a fucking stupid thing to do, and I wish that were more apparent to you. You did dumb things by your own account. That almost certainly wasn’t personal — it’s just that money and its involvement in journalism is extremely sensitive for very, very obvious reasons. Source: Journalist.
- jeremy_arnold 5y agoThank you for this amazing screencap!
- dky45 5y agoThank you for being marked legitimate by dang and using that privilege to level content-free, snarky replies that address absolutely none of the feedback you directly asked for in this thread! Now who isn’t engaging with criticism, again? Literally a journalist showed up to engage with you while you’re banging on that we don’t, so, your reaction here kinda speaks for itself and explains a lot more than you think. Good luck with your news startup.