3 ms·
> In their case, it's likely that the disease has multiple causative factors and the drug in question only treats one specific cause. The problem is that every
by bsder 5y ago
> In their case, it's likely that the disease has multiple causative factors and the drug in question only treats one specific cause.
The problem is that every drug that has targeted amyloid has failed to do jack shit in any cohort--not early, not late, not alien--none of them.
Any rational science system would conclude "The amyloid hypothesis for Alzheimer's is WRONG."
But, no, the bio people just plow on further because amyloid gets published, and funded, and, now, approved.
One day we'll look at this time as the alchemy period of neuro.
- aliasEli 5y agoJust the fact that we have not been able to find a medicine to reduce plaques does not imply that "The amyloid hypothesis for Alzheimer's is WRONG." Amyloid plaques are correlated with Alzheimer. AFAIK it is still an open question if they play a role in the causation of the symptoms.
- bsder 5y agoAmyloid plaques seem to be correlated with lots of things--they seem to be a general response to damage to the brain. Almost all of the evidence seems to point that amyloid plaques are not causative with Alzheimer's. The fact that every single drug (including this one!) targeting amyloid plaques (some of which are actually effective at reducing amyloid plaques) has failed to do anything for Alzheimer's suggests that amyloid plaques are the WRONG target.