4 ms·
This is different. With COVID, we knew the problem would solve itself in a couple years, even if we did nothing. We were in a race to save lives, not civilizati
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
This is different. With COVID, we knew the problem would solve itself in a couple years, even if we did nothing. We were in a race to save lives, not civilization.
Climate change will not solve itself like this. It will keep reducing food supply and habitable land, causing mass migrations that sooner or later will end in wars. Trying to wait it out is suicide.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Climate change will not solve itself like this.' Well, it will but in 10,000 years, so noone will be around for that except neo-cavemen or something
- ben_w 5y agoWorse, 100ka — without CO2 scrubbing, we’re likely to skip the next ice age entirely, possibly the one after too. https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16494 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16494
- spikels 5y ago> It will keep reducing food supply The global food supply is increasing: * See production numbers for key crops - all are still increasing. * See famine and hunger numbers all are still decreasing.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYeah, it's increasing, because we're strip-mining the soil. It won't last. I'll counter your points with two of mine: * See the problem of soil depletion. * Consider that crops are temperature-sensitive, and continued warming of the planet will be turning currently food-rich areas into zones where crops cannot be grown.
- dnautics 5y ago> Consider that crops are temperature-sensitive, and continued warming of the planet will be turning currently food-rich areas into zones where crops cannot be grown. This is probably the opposite of what is likely to happen, warmth is likely to enrich the food productivity of more northerly countries which tend to be politically more stable and have less distribution and corruption problems, resulting in more net food production, not less. > See the problem of soil depletion. Not related to the carbon dioxide issue. If you poison the carbon dioxide issue with unrelated or poorly-thought out assertations, you risk discrediting it.
- me_me_me 5y ago>This is probably the opposite of what is likely to happen, warmth is likely to enrich the food productivity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertification Have you seen the size of Africa? You are literally a character from futurama proposing to drop a giant ice cube into sea to cool it down.
- BobbyJo 5y agoThis is kind of a refutation of the parent, no? We knew things would work themselves out one way or another with COVID, so it was ok that we messed up. We know climate change won't work like that, so how then is COVID a good demonstration of our resolve and problem solving ability with respect to climate change?
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> We know climate change won't work like that, so how then is COVID a good demonstration of our resolve and problem solving ability with respect to climate change? It's not perfect. A better test would be a bona fide alien invasion. But the similarities were in: - High stakes - millions of lives are as high as you can get outside an actual existential risk - Global coordination needed for effective response - Cooperation of every individual needed for effective response In a way, COVID was a more pressing situation, and to the degree we've failed at both global coordination and individual cooperation, it suggests we'll do even worse with climate change. Some of the things the pandemic revealed are: - People don't trust the experts and authorities, way beyond the extent of reasonable doubt. - There's an infinite supply of pundits willing to sow doubt about the seriousness of the problem. - We can be staring death in the face, seeing our kin fall left and right, and many of us still reject effective means of mitigating the problem, seeing them as an "attack on their freedoms".