3 ms·
That was kinda Socrates' schtick: demand a definition, and then show that it wasn't a good one. Which was true, but not really all that useful. The best I can
by jfengel 5y ago
That was kinda Socrates' schtick: demand a definition, and then show that it wasn't a good one. Which was true, but not really all that useful.
The best I can say for it is that it shows the way people think they have definitions of things, but they don't. Push on pretty much any nontrivial definition and it will fail. That observation, at least, is kind of interesting, in that it shows the limits of the way we think about stuff.
But we do think about stuff, and both bio and silicon neural nets do a pretty good, messy job of it. If Socrates had pushed harder on that, he might have gotten some real work done about the nature of thought. Instead, he always just struck me as being kind of a jerk, rather than contributing anything.
- Cybotron5000 5y agoThe oracle at Delphi would beg to differ! ;) I take your point though, sort of… It’s maybe worth pointing out that we only know about Socrates from secondary sources: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_that_I_know_nothing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_that_I_know_nothing You could maybe think of him as playing devil’s advocate, or employing ‘reductio ad absurdum’ methods (even moving towards a precursor to some sort of scientific method perhaps?) …or maybe as employing sometimes useful methods of liberating people from irrational superstitions/unexamined beliefs, which eventually helped in some way to lead us to more modern ways of thinking? Have a read of this if you fancy, see what you think: https://users.manchester.edu/Facstaff/SSNaragon/Online/texts/201/-Essays/Russell,%20Value%20of%20Philosophy.pdf https://users.manchester.edu/Facstaff/SSNaragon/Online/texts...
- SuoDuanDao 5y agoI think he contributed something quite valuable - he pushed people into what we might call 'beginner mind', without which learning is impossible. His main thesis (as recounted by Plato) that any certainty is false certainty and that the only real wisdom comes from acknowledging one's own ignorance seems valuable indeed to me. I wonder what he would have made of today's statistical methods that try to bake that uncertainty in with a kind of recursive meta-certainty.