4 ms·
> Walking through my school library many years ago, I walked past a copy of Plato’s Republic, walked back, picked it up, and started reading. If you've never r
by kashyapc 5y ago
> Walking through my school library many years ago, I walked past a copy of Plato’s Republic, walked back, picked it up, and started reading.
If you've never read Plato before, I'd suggest not to start with the Republic — it is diving into the deep end of Plato. I'm saying this as someone who has recently completed Republic[1], and thoroughly enjoyed it (and fumed at it in some places).
Instead, get familiar with some of the earlier, and famous, Socratic dialogues: Euthyphro, Apology (this is referring to a "formal defense", i.e. apologia; not regret), Crito, et al — they're shorter, give you a great flavour of Socrates, and will prepare you for the Republic. An excellent English translation here is the Five Dialogues[2], a fine selection by Hackett Publishing. I'm happy that I started with this.
[1] There are many English translations; I'll strongly recommend the "Reeve Edition". This translation recasts the entire dialogue as direct speech, this makes it easy to keep track of the speakers. Ensure it is this Reeve-only edition (because Reeve also revised an earlier translation by Grube): https://www.hackettpublishing.com/republic https://www.hackettpublishing.com/republic
[2] https://www.hackettpublishing.com/five-dialogues https://www.hackettpublishing.com/five-dialogues
- cafard 5y agoHaven't seen the Reeve edition, but yes, the Republic is diving into the deep end.
- kashyapc 5y agoReeve is a long-time Plato scholar; do check out his edition. I also consulted in parallel the Allan Bloom translation[1], which is more literal and aimed at the "serious student", as he puts it. It also comes with a long (and controversial?) interpretative essay. [1] https://www.basicbooks.com/titles/allan-bloom/the-republic-of-plato/9780465094080/ https://www.basicbooks.com/titles/allan-bloom/the-republic-o...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whimsicalism 5y agoI found the Republic pretty accessible without much background in Plato. I had some exposure in philosophy and had read the Apologia, but otherwise had no Ancient Greek exposure. This absolutely could be a function of the translation I read though (I read Desmond Lee's)