4 ms·
>eliminates information asymmetries between workers and employers in wage bargaining. WOW! Never heard of this as an argument. I think it is a very good one fo
by ksec 5y ago
>eliminates information asymmetries between workers and employers in wage bargaining.
WOW! Never heard of this as an argument. I think it is a very good one for working class.
- LatteLazy 5y ago(not OP) There is good evidence that when wages are public knowledge minorities and women get paid more too... https://time.com/5353848/salary-pay-transparency-work/ https://time.com/5353848/salary-pay-transparency-work/
- ffggvv 5y agolikely everyone else just gets paid less in the interest of fairness.. this already happens at tech companies like stripe. "Oh we dont care how many competing offers you have or how qualified you are. we pay everyone the same in the name of "fairness".
- ncmncm 5y agoYou would like to think so, but if we compare Finnish to American payrolls, you would find instead that instead top management gets less, if anybody. But there is more... Economic prosperity is always most sensitive to what the bottom quarter gets paid, because they are who are obliged to spend what they get immediately. The greater general prosperity that results benefits everybody else, in sum, more than the increased minimum wage. This was recently demonstrated in Seattle, in practice. In short: no, you are 100% wrong. You should consider this good news.
- ffggvv 5y agoyou didn’t actually provide any proof to disprove my claim and then said i was 100% wrong. either way i don’t think we’re aspiring to be finland.
- ncmncm 5y agoWhich part of, "This was recently demonstrated in Seattle, in practice." were you not able to follow? 100% wrong, and evidently you don't consider it good news.
- ffggvv 5y agojust saying that and getting angry doesnt make it true. urban areas all boomed due to the roaring economy up until covid, especially powered by the large growth in the tech sector there and corporate tax cuts (and seattle's low state tax making it an attractive place to be locate). theres no evidence seattle magically helped everyone by raising minimum wages. likely seattle did fine despite the minimum wage increase, not because of them. Especially since you have to pay that much to attract workers there anyway because of the insane living costs. Which partially ballooned due to artificial price controls like that. and theres no measuring how many people got their jobs automated away or didnt get hired because of the wage increases. and seattle has also had an explosion of homelessness and violent crime.
- ncmncm 5y agoPerceiving anger where there is none reveals more than you probably intended.
- sagarm 5y agoFrom your own article: However, there isn’t enough research to definitively link pay transparency to pay equality. At U.S. government agencies, most of which are required to publicly release pay information, women make 81% of what men make, according to the 2017 report from the Institute for Women’s Policy Research. In the private sector, where the majority of companies don’t have pay transparency policies, women earn 79% of what their male counterparts make.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoMaybe. But imagine >enables transparency between workers and employers in wage bargaining.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoPrice transparency is necessary for the proper functioning of any market. Otherwise there is no clean signal of the supply and demand curves. Lack of price transparency results to inefficient markets, e.g. someone consistently ending up with outsized profits.
- RhysU 5y agoPrice transparency makes sense when goods are fungible. Employees are often not fungible.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy does it not make sense when goods are not fungible? The buyer and seller can ascertain how fungible the good they are interested in exchanging is. If it’s not, then the other prices will not matter as much. But more information is better than less information. Also, while employees might not be completely fungible (pretty much all are replaceable though on a long enough timeline), the employees are buying money from the employees, and that is fungible.
- RhysU 5y agoWhat's the value of a 1999 Camaro? How much should that number influence the price of last year's minivan? Arguing about the relevance of information to a transaction for some good is 1:1 with simply arguing about the transaction price for some good. Just haggle directly instead of in some meta fashion.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoHow does a person know which fields to pursue if they do not know wages? You have to look at the trends for which each wages are moving, where they are moving, the number of new job seekers in that field, the number exiting that field. It is much better now with the internet, but it was not long ago that if you did not know some in a specific business, you had no idea what they would be earning. For a kid in a lower income family, they might never know about what to study to get the top incomes. > What's the value of a 1999 Camaro? How much should that number influence the price of last year's minivan? Depends if the buyer is trying to decide between buying a 1999 Camaro or last year’s minivan. Just like a high school student might be trying to decide which field to go into.
- httpsterio 5y agoYep, I for example learned that my two bosses (CEO and CMO) in our roughly 20 person company took home roughly 100k in salaried income each, out of the 3 million or so turnover. Company earnings, turnover and profit, are easily found for all Finnish companies as well. It's pretty easy to weed out the companies on an unhealthy base. I also saw the salaries as a sign that they're in it for the long term as they could've easily taken home more but they also didn't feel the need to 'save' the company money so they had trust in the current market position and I felt comfortable asking for a 25% raise, which I also got. It's good to know where you stand among your peers and superiors.
- ksec 5y ago>in our roughly 20 person company took home roughly 100k in salaried income each And Fresh Grad from US are demanding 200K from FAANG.... I think it will be hard for countries not currently doing it to have this system in place. But we could at least start with price bracket. The biggest Win for me isn't the peer checking or market rate. It is that we can also stop HR and Recruiting Agency on their constant lying and BS. Constantly have to play games with them.
- ALittleLight 5y agoAssuming the parent comment is referring to earnings in Euros rather than USD they're talking about ~250k USD. It doesn't seem at all strange that leadership in a small company is making the same as entry developers at FAANG. For one, small business. Two, the company leadership gets more equity and a more interesting job.
- ksec 5y ago>in Euros rather than USD they're talking about ~250k USD. Not ~120K USD?
- ALittleLight 5y agoOops, you're right. I was more confident I knew the exchange rate than I should've been.