3 ms·
Trying to predict what a court would find fair use is incredibly difficult in the US, and it's hard to have much better accuracy than a coin flip if the answer
by jcranmer 5y ago
Trying to predict what a court would find fair use is incredibly difficult in the US, and it's hard to have much better accuracy than a coin flip if the answer is less than completely obvious. In practice, it seems that fair use is pretty much decided on a gut reaction first and then the analysis is motivated to arrive at that gut reaction.
A good example of that effect is Thomas's fair use analysis in Google v Oracle a few months ago, which can be summed up as "Google made buttloads of money from Android, Oracle saw not a dime, how can that be fair?" This kind of analysis I think tends to be the more the common one in courts. However, only one other justice agreed with that analysis; Breyer had 5 other justices sign onto his fair use analysis instead, which argues (in part) that transformativeness is more important than commerciality as a factor.
It remains to be seen how lower courts will apply Google v Oracle to fair use cases; if they will see it as something limited to software and ignore it for everything else. Indeed, I'm not certain that you'd see the same strong majority for a similar fair use ruling if it involved more traditional copyrighted content such as movies.
That said, I'm not sure that this is even distributing Netflix content in a way that violates copyright in the first place, which nullifies any need for fair use analysis period.