3 ms·
The goal of medicine is not reducing plaques, the goal is treating Alzheimer's. If the drug reduces plaques, but doesn't cure Alzheimer's, it's not a 'bad sign
by vkou 5y ago
The goal of medicine is not reducing plaques, the goal is treating Alzheimer's.
If the drug reduces plaques, but doesn't cure Alzheimer's, it's not a 'bad sign'. It simply means the drug doesn't work.
P-value hacking over and over again[1] until we finally get a study that shows us that the drug works is not the solution. [2]
[1] https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
[2] Unless the problem we are solving is "We have too much money that we need to spend on snake oil."
- tootie 5y agoI get it, I'm just saying it's not like they're selling essential oils or healing crystals. Reducing plaques could at least plausibly have some benefit. And I'm not arguing necessarily that the FDA are therefore justified, I'm just saying it's not fair to compare this to diet supplements. I was pointed to some other posts by this same guy about how bearish he is on amyloid plaque reduction as a plausible therapy which would have been useful context.
- jolux 5y ago> I get it, I'm just saying it's not like they're selling essential oils or healing crystals. You might have more of an argument here if this drug was only going to cost as much as essential oils or healing crystals, ironically. Would you suggest somebody go into debt for treatment with this product? It's likely to be quite expensive.