5 ms·
Of course it does. The working class doesn’t get stock options, vesting cliffs, inheritance, or capital gains! Or much of a savings account or 401k, for that m
by dangus 5y ago
Of course it does. The working class doesn’t get stock options, vesting cliffs, inheritance, or capital gains!
Or much of a savings account or 401k, for that matter.
The option to stop working for more than a few weeks or months takes you squarely out of the working class.
Basically, what I’m trying to say is that the parent comment to ours is attempting to advocate for taxing just the billionaires and not to tax the moderately wealthy so much. I think that’s a flawed argument, because the moderately wealthy don’t need help, and are perhaps even more wealthy than they realize.
- chrisseaton 5y agoPlenty of normal working class people get options if they work at a tech company.
- frockington1 5y agoWhen I worked at Home depot as a lot boy I got stock options
- WalterBright 5y ago> The working class doesn’t get stock options, vesting cliffs, inheritance, or capital gains! robinhood.com would beg to differ. Anyone can invest in the stock market and get capital gains.
- HWR_14 5y agoNot at the 500k level most of them aren't getting capital gains. Or is this "anyone can be a multimillionaire - just play the lottery and get lucky" level of technically true?
- WalterBright 5y agoThey're getting capital gains any time they sell a stock for more than they paid. There's no magic threshhold of $500k.
- HWR_14 5y ago>There's no magic threshhold of $500k. In the US in 2021 (aka, right now) the magic threshold for capital gains is $445,850-$501,600 depending on filing status. So you're technically correct that $500k isn't a magic threshold, but it's certainly in the middle of it. But more importantly, you're going down a technical rabbithole. The point of this comment chain is "what happens to people experiencing a one-time windfall capital gains of $500,000". The response was "what about RH investors". My point was they weren't making 500k, so it was irrelevant that they made income taxed as a capital gain. And I stand by that.
- WalterBright 5y ago> they weren't making 500k, so it was irrelevant that they made income taxed as a capital gain Sorry, but capital gains taxes start at $15,000.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Sorry, but capital gains taxes start at $15,000 Long-term capital gains less than $40,400 (or higher, depending on filing status) have a 0% rate.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> In the US in 2021 (aka, right now) the magic threshold for capital gains is $445,850-$501,600 depending on filing status. No, its not. The transition point between the top (20%) and middle (15%; the bottom is zero) marginal rate of long-term capital gains rates are either exactly the top or bottom of that range for 3 of 4 tax filing statuses (you left off married filing separately, which is much lower than even the low end), but that’s not a “magic threshold” by any reasonable definition.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt's both a magic number and a threshold. Married filing separately is just 1/2 of married filing jointly, which is how it should be.