3 ms·
> Why shouldn't someone be allowed to take it if they want to? That's the standard libertarian argument and we have an actual A/B experiment that shows what ha
by gumby 5y ago
> Why shouldn't someone be allowed to take it if they want to?
That's the standard libertarian argument and we have an actual A/B experiment that shows what happens.
People used to be able to market any old thing (such as "snake oil") to cure whatever they wanted to say. A regime was built up over time (culminating in 1963) that you had to demonstrate both safety and efficacy in order to sell a drug, and you could only describe the drug in ways you had demonstrated (which included manufacturing).
In 1994 Orrin Hatch (he of copyright maximization and senator from a state with a lot of "natural" scammers") got a law passed to say that anything "natural" was exempt from any FDA rules and sellers could say whatever they want. And as a result unlocked a huge snake oil business that preys on people when they are feeling most vulnerable. Fortunately most of those things are harmless nonsense but sadly not all.
If you decide there is no need to prove efficacy than nobody would spend time on it. And thus drug had its trials halted because nobody was being cured (not only do you not want to spend money on them, but it's unethical to expose people to side effects of a drug that doesn't help them.
The FDA is saying that even though it's unethical to do in a trial it's OK to do in the market.