3 ms·
Can you imagine the day that you declare a value on your house and the following week someone much richer than you comes along and tells you to "beat it; I just
by sokoloff 5y ago
Can you imagine the day that you declare a value on your house and the following week someone much richer than you comes along and tells you to "beat it; I just bought this place!"
- lovecg 5y agoWould do wonders for the Bay Area housing market! On a serious note, this proposal was originally coupled with a pretty radical (from our point of view) approach to land ownership. Land is closer to zero-sum than many other things (ignoring artificial islands etc.), so this forces a more efficient pricing/land use at the expense of doing away with private property rights for land.
- sokoloff 5y agoWorried that a competitor is catching up or threatening your market? Use your cash reserves to buy their factory out from under them. Don’t bother competing with Tesla, just make sure they can’t keep going once they get a little traction.
- ekelsen 5y agoImagine a reasonable policy rather than simplistic worst possible policy strawman. There are already many many laws that prevent abusive transactions in the current system, there's no reason that there wouldn't need to be similar laws to prevent abuse here either.
- ekelsen 5y agoOne can imagine reasonable policies around things like housing, my original two line reply was not meant to detail all the ways this would for all types of assets. I don't think anyone would have much of a problem with the simplistic scheme applied to rare art though.
- sokoloff 5y agoI do have a problem with that. I would prefer the Mona Lisa to remain in the hands of the Louvre than be regularly auctioned off. I would prefer American Gothic to remain in the hands of the Art Institute of Chicago, etc.
- ekelsen 5y agoTry to imagine a reasonable policy rather than assume the worst possible policy and then the outcomes that follow. One can imagine that public charities or government assets for example are exempt from such a scheme (since they don't pay tax anyway usually).
- sokoloff 5y agoI’m trying to imagine the reasonably predictable response to the policy that you sketched out. Removing private property rights is not a casual undertaking I agree and would require substantial thought and care, perhaps too much to be practically workable.
- ekelsen 5y agoYour replies so far don't seem to indicate you gave much thought to how such a system would reasonably work -- as evidenced by the assumption that art owned by charities or governments (institutions which don't pay tax) would also be up for auction.