3 ms·
Rules aren’t set in stone, they can change based on leaks like this. Assuming people find this information objectionable that’s a reasonable justification to p
by Retric 5y ago
Rules aren’t set in stone, they can change based on leaks like this.
Assuming people find this information objectionable that’s a reasonable justification to publish. In much the same way that leaking classified documents about questionable activities is morally justified, though illegal. Otherwise stamping secret on any evidence of say torture would work.
- mc32 5y agoI find the leak objectionable. It doesn’t disclose any nefarious doings or tax evasion. All it does is verify what we already know. No revelation. So this is more about shaming the witch rather than showing the witch did witchery.
- pmoriarty 5y ago"All it does is verify what we already know." Wait. What who already knows? I'm willing to bet that a lot of people who read this article did not already know the information contained within. As such the article serves to educate a lot of people, which is a positive development.
- mc32 5y agoI don’t think the author needed leaked data to present their objections to tax minimization.
- ethbr0 5y agoThey absolutely did. That something is legally within the bounds of the US tax code is public knowledge. That ultra-wealthy utilize something to an extent is not public knowledge. Which cuts to one of the central issues with viewing the US tax code as democratic: there's almost no transparency of use. The public might feel very different about a particular tax rule if they knew small businesses primarily used it, vs if they knew major corporations used it to shield 90% of their profits. The IRS should do a better job of anonymizing actual tax reports, and reporting out on patterns in aggregate.
- mlindner 5y agoTalk to any software engineer in the valley and they do a lot of the same stuff that Bezos does. The "trick" of not paying taxes until you sell the stock is something I do all the time. It's not a trick even.
- germinalphrase 5y agoBut it does provide direct evidence (that average people can link to prior knowledge) in support of those objections.
- zentiggr 5y agoAre you also opposed to the Watergate leaks? Snowden's leaks? the Pentagon Papers? and a lot of less famous leaks of restricted information that have led to exposure and sometimes even justice for people who otherwise would have hid behind "legal" defenses for immoral or flat out illegal acts of their own? I served in the Navy - I had a prety high clearance just to do the job I did. I know the value of classifying or otherwise restricting information. And I know the value of breaking those rules to expose those who would hide their crimes. I consider the current tax code a recipe/playbook/script for stealing from the American public.
- mc32 5y agoYou are presenting an example of government cover ups or crimes. This is not the government doing something wrong, not even a private person doing something wrong. It’s simple some vigilante having a vendetta against someone they don’t like and using illegal mans to skewer them. The case they have is known. We know the loopholes. Let's as close them. Don’t go out on personal or vendettas of virtue when it aids nothing. There is nothing new here. Jeff, as much as I dislike his company, didn’t commit a crime.
- Retric 5y agoIt’s your option that these people did nothing wrong. However, many legal things like adultery are still objectionable and people object to this.
- mc32 5y agothe more appropriate comparison in your case would be an open marriage where one partner complains the other is cheating. They set up the rules then complain someone is taking advantage of the rules. I myself would like Jeff to pay more in taxes. I think the super wealthy pay too little in terms of parentage, but I should be upset with the Congress/IRS not the wealthy.
- Retric 5y ago
- Dracophoenix 5y ago>>Rules aren't set in stone The problem with that argument is who get to make that decision? Would you still be saying that if someone leaked you tax records to the general public?
- Retric 5y agoYep, I have no objection to people leaking any of my tax details beyond identify theft.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoAnybody who has your full tax records has your name, your current and previous addresses, social security number, how much you make, your place of work, the name(s) of your children (if you file as head of household or for child tax credits), etc. What makes you think this treasure trove of information isn't going be used for identity theft? It's like saying you have no objections to someone breaking into your car or house and stealing your stuff, so long as they don't take your driver's license or registration papers and pretend to be you.
- DynamicStatic 5y agoTbh i think tax records should be public. It is in Sweden for example and that works pretty well.