4 ms·
That's a very welcome addition, but I'm guessing these won't be available for third-party "browsers", just like content blocking extensions? That decision make
by lxgr 5y ago
That's a very welcome addition, but I'm guessing these won't be available for third-party "browsers", just like content blocking extensions?
That decision makes absolute sense for most in-app browsers (that depend on WKWebView for functionality that isn't generic web browsing), but for actual browser apps, content blockers are sorely missing.
- null_object 5y ago> but for actual browser apps, content blockers are sorely missing. A simple, but functionally very basic app that does ad-blocking on iOS is Firefox Focus. This might cover most people's basic privacy needs, but not as a fully-functioning experience (I use this more for 'one-off' site visits, where I don't want to be tracked, see ads, or have any persistent record of my visit on the device). But for a fully-featured browser with user-configurable content, JavaScript, CSS and ad-blocking, then the little-known iCab Mobile[0] does almost everything that a desktop browser can do in terms of privacy and content-control. [0]https://apps.apple.com/us/app/icab-mobile-web-browser/id308111628 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/icab-mobile-web-browser/id3081...
- lxgr 5y agoWhat, iCab is still around!? Amazing, thanks! I use Firefox on iOS myself (which supports ad blocking under the name of "enhanced privacy protection") but might give it a shot.
- spupy 5y agoFYI Firefox Focus can also be used as content blocker in Safari. Of course, this doesn't offer the full protection as using Firefox Focus directly.
- null_object 5y ago> FYI Firefox Focus can also be used as content blocker in Safari. Yes I know. But my reply was in response to a question specifically about ad-blocking for non-Safari browsers on iOS.
- threatofrain 5y agoA bit of a tangent, but does anyone have suggestion for the best ad or content blockers for MacOS and iOS Safari?
- leejoramo 5y agoI have used iCab for over 20 years across Mac OS 8, Mac OS X, and iOS. Prior to the built-in inspector with Firefox and later Safari/Chrome, iCab was the best web debugging tool I used. iCab lost many advantages (and disadvantages) when it transitioned from its own engine to WebKit, but it still is filled with power user features All iOS power users should check out iCab
- twobitshifter 5y agoContent blockers do work for 3rd party browsers AFAIK. I use Firefox on iOS and to my understanding Magic Lasso content blocker is what’s blocking the ads. I think that since the Firefox browser is really safari and the blocker is implemented at a lower level, the content blocker just works.
- lxgr 5y agoNo, Firefox for iOS has its own built-in ad blocker, as far as I know. For example, iOS Chrome definitely does show ads for me on the same pages that Firefox manages to block them on, with the same content blocker iOS settings.
- twobitshifter 5y agoThanks that’s interesting - I enabled enhanced strict tracking protection, which I thought was just related to tracking across sites. It is apparently good enough at ad blocking that I have not noticed.
- hs86 5y agoAdGuard for iOS offers both Safari Content Blockers and a local VPN/DNS for 3rd party apps. The significant difference is that Safari can apply cosmetic filters, while other browsers like Chrome leave ugly placeholders where the ads would have been. Interestingly, AdGuard for Android allows full ad-blocking + cosmetic filtering in Chrome by installing a certificate that enables local MitMing of your TLS connections. I am both impressed and creeped out by this hack and how reliable it seems to work. :)
- behnamoh 5y agoHow is this not anti-competition? "My browser can enjoy extensions but third-party browsers cannot because we care about the privacy of our users".
- tomComb 5y agoAs you probably know, other browsers are just shells around Safari - so there has never even been a pretense of competition in iOS browsers.
- gnicholas 5y agoIsn't there a Safari Webview that has access to most of the features of regular Safari? https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=trjs0tcd https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=trjs0tcd
- saagarjha 5y agoYes, but the API to interact with it is fairly limited.
- ornornor 5y agoAs an alternative, I’ve been using nextdns with great success to block most ads in any browser and most apps (but not YouTube sadly)