3 ms·
Because of a long tradition of the system libraries being fucked. All this stuff started in the days of Windows XP, which shipped with such a meagre selection
by michaelt 5y ago
Because of a long tradition of the system libraries being fucked.
All this stuff started in the days of Windows XP, which shipped with such a meagre selection of codecs you couldn't even play DVDs.
And the codecs you could download? Either they cost money (i.e. most users wouldn't have them), or they were dodging license costs by some questionable means, or they had bigger aspirations than just providing a mere codec (flash/realplayer/quicktime)
VLC arose out of that and became popular because, by ignoring the system codecs, it could actually play the damn file.
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoVLC also has the advantage of being developed in France, where the legal system does not recognise software patents.
- simondotau 5y agoReally! My respect for France has gone up a few notches.
- namdnay 5y agoDon't get too excited, in France there's a tax on all storage devices (sd cards, usb sticks, hdds, laptops, phones etc) to help subsidise the record and film industry...
- carlob 5y agoWe have that in Italy too, but at least that means that ripping CDs or DVDs is entirely legal. It's actually called private copy contribution.
- nephanth 5y agoYep it actually came from Germany, and was afterward adopted by a lot of european countries
- drw85 5y agoGermany has that too. Even on paper, since you could copy pages under copyright.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nephanth 5y agoNote that internal HDDs aren't taxed under this tax, only external ones. (So if you don't want to pay it, you can just buy a SATA HDd and an adaptor). Phones are taxed though (yes this doesn't make any sense technically)
- simondotau 5y agoIs the tax on a phone's storage capacity or its overall retail price?
- nephanth 5y agoOn the storage capacity
- simondotau 5y agoHonestly, I'd take that trade. A narrow, stupid tax is definitely the lesser of two evils here. (Especially as it means I'd have a moral license to pirate whatever I wish!)
- giantrobot 5y agoThere was a lot of back and forth [0] over this back when Firefox added support for system libraries. The FOSS purists only wanted to support codecs they could include in Gecko (long before OpenH264) while the pragmatists wanted to make a useful web browser. Support for system libraries first appeared on mobile platforms because it was essential. At the time (ca 2011/12) the likes of YouTube and Vimeo were only delivering MP4 to mobile clients. The purists seemed to think that somehow if Firefox held the line on (likely but not guaranteed) unencumbered formats/codecs that every content producer would see the light and go with those objectively worse codecs with no hardware acceleration for video content. This completely ignored the fact that Flash was common on desktops and supported encumbered codecs just fine. It was in fact the primary delivery vehicle for them. The NPAPI content hole let the purists be intransigent while actually using content on the web. They were also ignoring the design of the HTML5 video tag that encouraged inclusion of multiple source formats and some sort of fallback including object embeds. As for Microsoft they were still pushing the various Windows Media codecs as the One True Way in the Windows XP and Vista eras. They had to support MP4 with Windows 7 because every smartphone and most stand alone cameras were capturing video in MPEG-4 codecs if not file formats. [0] https://groups.google.com/g/mozilla.dev.platform/c/-xTei5rYThU/m/DkM9AIbkNNIJ https://groups.google.com/g/mozilla.dev.platform/c/-xTei5rYT...
- cpeterso 5y agoMicrosoft still doesn't include basic codecs like H.264 in some Windows editions ("N" and "KN" for some regions in the EU and Korea), but those users can download Microsoft's Windows Media Feature Pack to get the codecs: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/fix-video-audio-problems-firefox-windows https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/fix-video-audio-problem...