3 ms·
> But what you won't capture is that these two goods are both providing lighting, and that the switch from one to another provides a sharp drop in the price of
by oblio 5y ago
> But what you won't capture is that these two goods are both providing lighting, and that the switch from one to another provides a sharp drop in the price of light that is not captured by the change in prices of either in isolation.
I wonder if there was any way to compute light emitted per source. Then you could calculate a price per unit of light and whale-oil lamps would be obliterated by incandescent light builds which would in turn be obliterated by LED light bulbs.
- cbhl 5y agoPlanet Money had an episode where they used the metric "minutes of light per day's wages". Here's the transcript: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/503769949 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/503769949 But there are qualitative changes that aren't captured by this -- street lights are brighter and whiter now than they were in the 1990s for example, and those were brighter than oil lamps before them.
- azernik 5y agoNote: that's a more accessible podcast/write-up of the paper I linked in my comment as [1]. If people want the denser in (in both good ways and bad) version, look up there.
- azernik 5y agoThere is! That paper I linked does exactly that. It uses light to illustrate the point because it's particularly easy to calculate the comparative amount of utility per unit of cost regardless of technology, and show how it diverges from what naive price indices would show. It's harder for something like batteries, where there are multiple relevant performance parameters to reduce to one utility heuristic. And good luck when the utility is subjective (clothes), still under study (food and nutrition), or ill-defined (media).
- KorematsuFred 5y agoYou might like this as well: https://www.humanprogress.org/how-the-cost-of-light-has-fallen-by-a-factor-of-500000/ https://www.humanprogress.org/how-the-cost-of-light-has-fall...
- azernik 5y agoYup! That's a condensed version of a BBC write-up of that first paper I linked. Super influential in the field, but only percolated into popular media in the last decade.