3 ms·
Agree with most of what you said but: > > especially in the US > The app was deployed in Australia. Australia has an even worse equivalent of US National Sec
by lmm 5y ago
Agree with most of what you said but:
> > especially in the US
> The app was deployed in Australia.
Australia has an even worse equivalent of US National Security Letters, allowing individual workers to be compelled to plant backdoors etc..
- ungamedplayer 5y agoNot without notice of the company, and not for wide spreaed distribution, ie targeted enforcement.
- lmm 5y ago> Not without notice of the company Oh? The reports I read were that they could compel an individual to do something and not tell their employer.
- ajdlinux 5y agoThe reports you read were likely based on commentary from techies who have no understanding about law, plus a handful of lawyers involved with digital rights organisations that have an incentive to play up the significance of the legislation a bit / talk about worst-case scenarios, worst possible interpretations of a dangerous law and the broadest possible interpretation of who constitutes a "designated communications provider". The government has stated that's not how they interpret the legislation, as the service provider will be the employer not the employee, and I don't think government lawyers are in the habit of arguing that the government _doesn't_ have power to do something. I'm as suspicious about the Assistance and Access Bill as anyone, but the "telling an employee to implement a backdoor without telling their employer" is really a red herring and I don't know why the Australian tech community was so keen to go along with that.
- the-dude 5y agoWhy would such a law target an employee, when as you claim, it targets the employer indirectly too? Why not leave it at the employer? Just because won't cut it.
- Marsymars 5y ago> I don't think government lawyers are in the habit of arguing that the government _doesn't_ have power to do something. Eh, from where I'm sitting, that's a pretty common tactic to pacify opposition to legislation that grants the government too much power.
- hulahoof 5y agoI was also under the impression this can be served to individuals without the knowledge of their employer, leaving the individual in a position where they can consult a single lawyer about the legality of the request and face jail time for discussing the request with anyone else (including employers). I would need to re-read the act, but the gov website[1] indicates you are correct that these requests are served to organisations and not individuals excepting sole traders. [1] https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/about-us/our-portfolios/national-security/lawful-access-telecommunications/myths-assistance-access-act https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/about-us/our-portfolios/natio...