8 ms·
"[Sci fi] is also crammed with clichés that are superficially plausible but which don’t hang together when you look at them too closely." This seems the most v
by ctdonath 15y ago
"[Sci fi] is also crammed with clichés that are superficially plausible but which don’t hang together when you look at them too closely."
This seems the most valuable bit of the essay. There are so many things that we "want", until we get them.
Recalls a recent article (anyone have a link? been looking for it) wherein the future of human space travel is deemed nonexistent because lobbing humans to another place is so hard with so few places worth expending that effort for. Do we all want inter-planetary/stellar/galactic space travel? of course we say yes, but faced with expending a lifetime (or a thousand) to get there and burning all of Earth's resources to do it we'd say no.
Closer to home, there are so many products and services we want, yet go nigh unto unused when we shell out hard-earned money for them. Yeah, I want XYZ, but upon acquisition I move right on to acquiring PDQ instead of using XYZ to anywhere close to its full potential. I've got a thousand unread books as a testament to this.
Not quite sure where I'm going with this or why, but his point did seem salient.
- jokermatt999 15y agoRecalls a recent article (anyone have a link? been looking for it) wherein the future of human space travel is deemed nonexistent because lobbing humans to another place is so hard with so few places worth expending that effort for. Do we all want inter-planetary/stellar/galactic space travel? of course we say yes, but faced with expending a lifetime (or a thousand) to get there and burning all of Earth's resources to do it we'd say no. I'm fairly sure that was actually another blog post by Charles Stross, the author of this article. He also occasionally posts here as cstross, if you're looking for his comments on his work.
- PaulHoule 15y agoThis isn't the case for A.I. Better A.I. means we can automate more things and make more profit. You can take that to the bank. It's the kind of thing where you can make a 10% improvement and get 10% extra returns. Space travel has the issue that a 10% improvement doesn't get you anywhere. It's also bad to conflate travel to earth orbit, the moon, other planets and interstellar travel. A mission to mars, for instance, is plausible with technology we've got. Difficult, expensive, yes, maybe not worth it, but it could be done. To go to another star you need to find a planetoid's mass of antimatter -- and that's just the beginning of your trouble. I was working on a story about an interstellar war and came to the conclusion that, if you want to attack a world around another star, there's no need to put an atomic warhead on your missiles, because the energy of fission or fusion is nothing compared to what it takes to accelerate something to 10% of light speed.