4 ms·
Energy density is a meaningless measure for cars. $ per mile isn't. If you have a heavier battery, you just need a bit more of it to drive the same amount of mi
by jillesvangurp 5y ago
Energy density is a meaningless measure for cars. $ per mile isn't. If you have a heavier battery, you just need a bit more of it to drive the same amount of miles. It just boils down to cost in the end. You can also trade weight for mileage and have less battery. That lowers the cost and improves the mileage. Apparently Tesla has pushed internal cost per kwh of storage below 100$ now. That price is going to drop further.
But lets look at actual mileage at two roughly comparable cars (same vendor and brand):
Mustang Mach E 88kwh/300 mile EPA range. Or about 3.4 mile per kwh.
2021 Ford Mustang Mach 1 does 5.6 gallons per 100 miles (with the 8 cylinder engine). Or about 18 miles per gallon.
https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/noframes/43610.shtml https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/noframes/43610.shtml
These are just official numbers, take them with a grain of salt. Also, both cars have a couple of variants obviously. Particularly the petrol mileage is likely to get a lot worse over the lifetime of the car as the engine wears out. This is less of a thing with EVs. And you probably have to drive the petrol Mustang like a nun to actually get 5.6 gallons per 100 miles. Likewise EVs have different mileage depending on driving style, temperature, etc. Lets just say they are both a little bit worse typically.
But they are nice numbers to work with and they are based on real world efficiency rather than archaic notions of potential energy, energy density, etc.
With these numbers, 1 gallon is roughly the equivalent of a bit over 5kwh when it comes to mileage in a gas guzzler like the Mustang. Cost for that from a super charger depends on a few factors. Likewise for a gallon of fuel (e.g. taxes). On a super charger at 28cents per kwh, it's like filling your tank for about 1.40$ per gallon , which would be a pretty good gas price that most of the world has not seen in a few decades. A super charger is probably the most expensive place to get your electricity. So, you might do better if you have cheap nightly grid rates or rooftop solar. There are lots of ways to get that number down. But 1.4$ per gallon equivalent is a lot cheaper than petrol. About 2x depending which state you live. Closer to 3x in some states. EVs are a bit heavier than petrol cars of course. But not 10x. Nowhere close to that. Maybe 1.5x or so. Half the energy cost per mile at the price of 50% extra weight is not a bad choice.
That's the reason people are switching to electric. It's just cheaper. It gets better when you also consider maintenance cost. It gets better still when battery and vehicle prices continue to drop. Purchase price of EVs is currently still slightly higher than the equivalent petrol car. But not for very long apparently.
Your mileage may vary but nowhere near 10x. More like 0.5x.
- gameswithgo 5y agoEnergy density on mass is not entirely meaningless. A heavier car requires larger tires. That makes the tires a more expensive continuing cost, and creates more particulate pollution. A heavier car also requires larger brakes and pads (though electric cars can offset this with regen). A heavier car also puts more wear onto the roads. A heavier car also makes the car slower at a given horsepower, and have worse handling characteristics. So metrics like energy per kg, energy per volume, and energy per $ can all be relevant.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoIn theory yes. In practice, the mach e handles very nicely compared to the mach 1. You'd not buy the latter in favor of the former for it's raw performance as the mach e is simply faster. Brake pads last longer because of regenerative breaking (i.e. you hardly use your brakes at all). Tire wear on a mustang is something to be mindful of. But then doing donuts seems to be a thing with these cars. Ridiculous torque has a price. You see the same pattern with other EVs and increasingly high performance electrical sports cars breaking all sorts of records. Energy per kg is relevant when weight matters. For example in electrical planes. In cars, $ per mile is the one to focus on. Of course that continues to improve as energy density improves so they are somewhat linked.
- JeffL 5y agoMost people do most of their charging at home. Our off peak cost at night is 5 cents per kWh. Much, much cheaper than superchargers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ta2162 5y ago>Our off peak cost at night is 5 cents per kWh. Must be nice. Triple that in California (where most EVs are).
- 5y ago