14 ms·
My initial guess was "WRMSR, and the 64-bit version of WRMSR". Fortunately, this appears to be an actually new finding rather than the memorable case a few year
by userbinator 5y ago
My initial guess was "WRMSR, and the 64-bit version of WRMSR". Fortunately, this appears to be an actually new finding rather than the memorable case a few years back of someone claiming to have discovered something that was clearly documented in the datasheet.
The whole idea that there's a "red state" and a bunch of others on a CPU, normally hidden, should immediately raise the attention of many who wonder what those extra modes can do, and more interestingly, why they're hidden. From the (very little!) research I've done, it appears this is not unlike SGX where only Intel has the key[1] to some part of the hardware you bought from them, and based on some leaked internal documents, it's very plausible that this is indeed a backdoor which only they can use. Ostensibly, for debugging purposes. Here's a previous comment I made on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26521359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26521359
[1] If these keys were leaked, which I very much hope will happen at some point, no doubt the "security" community will be heavily against it and spread plenty of FUD about how it makes everyone's computers insecure. But IMHO it should be eagerly awaited and received with the same optimism as the other DRM key leaks (HDCP, HDDVD, etc.) --- it is a path to freedom.
- londons_explore 5y agoI assume it will be a public-private keypair with some challange-response mechanism, so no amount of reverse engineering could extract the key from a CPU. Intel probably have the master private key on a hardware security module, and have set up some API so their engineers can do the challange-response dance to get into RED mode. But after poweroff, it'll need to be done again. If that's the setup, the key won't leak. There are probably only 5 hardware cards in the world with the key, and they're probably set to not allow key extraction. To get the key, you would need to physically steal the card, and have an exploit for silicon designed to be key storage... Not going to happen.
- jhoechtl 5y agoAnd the key on the silicon would auto-destroy if a fraudulent attempt is recognized.